worst potato salad I've every had I couldn't even give it away to my friends because they. say the same I thought this would be a easy side for a decent get together I thought wrong. normally Sam's brands are good just this time it's not for me .

Salty, too mayo-y and not my cup of tea...I accidentally ordered the loaded potatoes somehow instead of my favorite, the plain old potato salad, which is, to me, very very good. I didn't realize it until I opened it and took a bite. Yikes, not what I expected to taste, and I tried having some more once I realized my error in case it was just the shock of not what I expected, but nope, this is a total miss for me, if it was less salty and had less mayo...maybe.

This was a great idea for summer cook outs until we tried it. All 4 people who ate it said it had the same, strange background taste that none of us could identify. It's not a spoiled or bad taste, just an off weird flavor. Some seasoning or added flavor that we didn't like. I ended up tossing out the rest of it.

the sample I tasted was amazing, so much so that I circled around to pick up and place in my basket %26 meal planned around this side dish. fast forward a few days and I'm excited to have supper and this was a soupy mess that didn't taste good at all 👎👎👎👎👎

The potato salad it great, reasonable, good value, BUT there is a major issue, the package is not sealed, anybody could remove the snap on top lid, and the product is exposed to whatever someone decides to add.. this is a major RED flag, that container should be sealed with a barrier film or something that can prevent someone from adding to the contents without any indicator that the product was previously opened.. Sam's club could or should immediately pull these containers off the shelves until they are properly sealed. The container I purchased was not sealed and anybody could just pop off the lid and expose the product to whatever they wanted to do with it.. definitely a very high probability that this has happened because nothing holds the lid in place.. thank you!!!!

It was the worst tasting potato salad I ever had. Most of the three pounds went in the trash as fast as I could put it there. I was born in Idaho 73 years ago and I have tasted many recipes for it. Usually I make it from scratch. I will never take this shortcut again.

I was looking for a pasta salad but they were out so I looked around for something else that would work and came across this. I've never even heard of Loaded Baked Potato Salad so I decided to try it. I is absolutely delicious!! What a surprise after dinner my husband said why couldn't you heat it up a little bit wouldn't it taste like a loaded baked potato?? Trying it tonight!!

WARNING DON'T BUY THIS DISQUISTING POTATO SALAD!!!! I only could eat about two fork fulls and stopped because of the terrible taste!!! My Brother and other friends had the same experience. Now on the other hand if you try the other Sam's club potato salad that comes in a 5lb container you'll really enjoy that, and to be brutally honest I'm shocked they are still selling that NASTY LOADED POTATO SALAD!!!!!!

I had high hopes for this potato salad. I've had another “loaded” type potato salad before and it was delish! This one is just lacking in that “loaded potato” flavoring. It just tastes blah. No one at the party cared for it and it ended up in the trash, unfortunately.

It was good, loaded with the stuff you'd expect. I liked it quite a bit.