Open a jar of mayonnaise and you have this. I was so looking forward to this being wonderful. It was awful. No one wanted to eat it. Seriously it had very little potatoes pieces but it was definitely creamy …

Sour cream flavor is way too powerful, other flavors hardly come through, Like 75% of the flavor in this thing is just sour cream. I guess a lot of people like that about this potato salad but I sure as heck didn't.

It's got a good taste but the texture is what you have to get over. The potatoes are sliced lengthwise and not in chunks. So, if you can handle that, you're okay.

others in my household liked it and it would be great for a grab-n-go for a pot luck, but I found the bacon and smoked flavoring too overpowering for my taste buds.

This was horrible, it has way too much mayo or sour cream. Not the potato salad for me, it went in the trash and this girl loves everything and I hate wasting food.

My husband and I are not picky eaters. I have purchased the regular potato salad many times. The loaded is awful. Leave a very distinct after taste. Very goopy.

Tasted mostly of sour cream/mayonnaise. Not edible for any of us 4 who tried it. Wish I would have sampled it in the club first cause I would not have bought it.

I had placed a pick up order the weekend of easter only to find out I was given a 3 month expired potato salad. Luckily it wasnt everyones go to side and that I didn't get sick.

My husband and I couldn't even eat it. It had a very thick texture and the flavor was too rich for us. We threw it away. Not appetizing! We plan to ask for a refund during our next trip to Sam's Club.

worst potato salad I've every had I couldn't even give it away to my friends because they. say the same I thought this would be a easy side for a decent get together I thought wrong. normally Sam's brands are good just this time it's not for me .