At first, the sponges had a formula that did clean. Today, they are glorified sponges that do not last. They break into pieces that make it more of a chore to clean after them. The scratches stay scratched, they do not disappear. Too expensive for such a cheap product. Last time that I purchase this product.

This product started disintegrating nearly immediately rendering it useless in cleaning my tub. The cleaning agent in the sponge did seem to work, but if you cant use the sponge beyond a small 12 in area before needing to throw it away it isn't a good purchase. I've seen your responses to other about this same complaint about how it is made to break down over time & use. But come on, almost immediately is a bit ridiculous.

used this because of the previous reviews -it absolutely scarred, removed the wall coating and discolored my walls .i had to totally recoat the wall and repaint it was normal wear, a slight brush scuff from from walking by or a bag to take off the scuff, worst results, simple water on a rag actually worked better. sorry, don't normally take the time to review but seriously this was worse than than doing nothing at all shame on you for the false claims

The original Mr. Clean magic erasers came with 2 sides. 1 of them was a sponge like substance. The other was like a scrubbing pad. These new 1's fall apart within seconds while scrubbing. I thought my husband just picked up the wrong type, but it seems like they are all the same. Can I get my money back for all of the packages I have purchased trying to get the right 1 that will actually work? I am furious!!!

Owning 3 dogs, 1 of which is a bloodhound, is terrible on walls. Bloodhound slobber gets flung everywhere and is like slug slime and can be very hard to remove. Magic Eraser makes me so happy every time I use it!!! It takes ALL the dirt and dried dog slobber off my walls and doors and never removes the paint. I use them constantly!;-)

I have used the magic eraser many times and never had a problem until now. I used it on a spot on the exterior of my house hoping to remove a mark. Instead of removing the mark, it left a stain on my house that looks like the spot is always wet. I'm afraid I'll have to get my house painted to cover it, unless anyone has any suggestions as to how to fix it?

Your product as a whole is fantastic. The problem is...
Marketing/Sales is based on affordability instead of quality. Why not advertise as “New and improved”, providing one quality product for all? The least expensive (which still costs too much), is not worth the money spent. The Magic Eraser falls apart immediately upon use, requiring the use of more erasers to get the job done. While the most expensive Magic Eraser works great, and does allow for getting the job done, with one eraser.
Why not save money by producing one quality eraser, and passing on the savings onto the consumer?

We want to get our house ready to sell and would like to avoid painting all the walls. I tried M.E. on a wall with various little marks from something bumping into it. The marks largely disappeared but the wall does look a little blotchy. Maybe the M.E. removes the paint (light beige) a bit. Is there a preferred way to move the M.E. on a wall -- up and down strokes, across? Larger area than the spot?

I just used a magic eraser I've had laying around for years. Oh my gosh! I used it in the tub and it really does look like a new tub! I could not believe it. Comet and Ajax wouldn't even clean off that ground in dirt on the non-slip surface. Minimal scrubbing and it was white again! I kept telling my daughter how amazing that is and she said I should be on a commercial!!

I mean what does this not clean. It takes off hard to clean scratches from furniture, counters or walls. Your kid wrote on the wall with a nonwashable marker? This will take it off. Got scratches on your toilet seat from the metal bidet? This will take it off. Got a dirty bathtub and dont want to ruin it with bleach? This gets the job done. We love it for all kinds of job