Hundreds and hundreds of watermelons were in the store. Stacks of them in mini Department when I got one home I opened it and it was terrible. 100% uneditable I knew I wouldn’t get back to the store to bring it back so I ended up throwing the entire thing away. It had no flavor no taste. It was awful. And because we live on a retirement budget it’s always hard to throw six dollars in the garbage.

We all know how difficult it is to select a watermelon. Looks beautiful on the outside, meets all the crucial tips that your grandparents told ya about, you get it home, cut into it just to find out that you’ve selected a dud. This watermelon wasn’t ripe at all, it was mostly colorless inside. White - like rind pretty much throughout. Did taste it, crunchy but obviously there was no juicy watermelon flavor. Had to toss it to the woods. Perhaps, I select a better one next time or take granny with me!! LOL!

Somebody spit a huge amount into the watermelon pallet container. Many of the watermelon’s were coated in spit. Absolutely disgusting! No way of knowing if an employee did it or if a customer did it. Needs to have a closer. I kept on things like that. Watermelon was OK after being sterilized. Lost my appetite for it though.

I was frankly surprised at how good this was, but had volunteered to bring a melon to a potluck got a dozen people. It was the only melon I could find anywhere for an online pickup. I found the taste was sweet and not mushy texture. It was just enough in 4 inch chunks served in a flat Pyrex rectangular pan because there was NO WASTE. Unlike most large melons, where only the heart is sweet, the flavor was consistently sweet down to the white rind. Will try it again!

I know how to pick good watermelons. The last couple that I have chosen have been very sweet and had good flavor and texture. The only thing, is I wish I could purchase non GMO melons. The supposed seedless ones that Sams sells have seed all over in them and the last two were black seeds - smaller, yes, but still black seeds that I don't care for.

Usually buy watermelon from here all the time and been happy with price. Was wanting a watermelon and couldn't find one at any of the local store that were not cut up. Came to Sam's and found one and couldn't believe the wanted $8.00 for a watermelon i had no choice but to buy it for a party reason but was truly shocked at the price. Sam's makes money and to charge $8.00 for it was upsetting because it wasn't even sweet at all ended up throwing it away.

We've had some very good watermelons in the past. But this year we got one even the dog and chickens wouldn't eat. It was so dry, it had a huge crack down the middle when we cut it open. We just don't take the risk anymore and purchase watermelons elsewhere. On a positive note, they did give us our money back for it. Gotta Love SAMs even if we don't always love their watermelon.

This watermelon was, without a doubt, the poorest quality I’ve ever bought. Even a single star rating feels generous. The interior was so mushy, it could be scooped out with a spoon, resembling soup more than fruit. I considered returning it, but that would require keeping it until my next trip to Sam’s Club. Consequently, I decided to discard it and absorb the financial loss. Despite my fondness for watermelons, I’ve resolved to hold off on buying another until summer. It was a truly disappointing experience. What

Not sure where these are coming from but, the water melon was picked to early and had a bitter after taste with some sections of it hard like I was chewing on the rind, I know this is not an easy thing to do, picking a watermelon at the right time of ripeness from the fields and still make it to market while being fresh, but this is the second watermelon I have bought from the Walmart chains that has been terrible. Following all of the advise and experience from my youth of finding a watermelon that is sweet, looking at the tail of the vine, checking for the thickness of the lines, the color and the weight, did nothing. I used to go with my dad to pick up watermelons out of the fields in Georgia, neither of these purchases would have made it on our truck, and they should not have made it into the stores.

Watermelon at Sam’s is hit or miss. You are taking a chance when purchasing this item. We have had good and bad melons from Sam’s. You can get your money back in the event that you pick one that is not so crisp or juicy, but then you’ve wasted your time and you have no melon for the family. I would not recommend these unless you have a kit of time in your hands and don’t really care if you have a good melon or not.