These watermelons were very good. I went back and bought more.

Great tasting watermelon. Juicy and sweet!

Sweet and juicy.

The watermelon was basically tasteless. Probably pulled green. Full of small seeds, some light cream color and some seeds were blackish. Not recommended!

The watermelon was tasteless and overly soft. Not with the price charged. When you have a price of 8.99 on a watermelon you hesitate. 1st thought “9 bucks?” 2nd thought “Man, this better be worth it.” It wasn’t. The inside of the watermelon seemed that it already had turned and started it’s spoiling stage.

Passed the thump on the side test (my Dad said a hollow sound means ripe), tasted good. Plenty juicy. Not as sweet as I'd expect the first day. Day two the sweetness was just right.

Watermelons can be delicious or they may not meet the "hype." As they say, you may not be able to tell a book by its cover but you can tell the state of the melon by the THUMP. This is not always true, as my melon had a nice "D" major thump but had a few defects on the inside. Overall, I was able to salvage a few cups of melon so it was not a complete disappointment.

Not so sweet

Watermelon was dry no juice in it whatsoever

Price was right for the size of the watermelon. Very flavorful. Tired of getting overpriced melons at the local supermarket and have no flavor.