I think if your picking out your own watermelon you can pick out the best ones I picked out 2 on Saturday and juice half of one and my daughter got the other whole one they were good to us.I think the problem comes in when a shopper is picking it out most don't really care what they get, that's why so many negative reviews.

If you want a watermelon that has the consistency of a potato and absolutely no flavor or sweetness, then you are in luck. This is by far the worst watermelon I have ever bought. My hands and countertop weren't even sticky after cutting it up. Don't waste your money.

I had bought one in the store and before I could get out the parking lot saw a mold and soft spot on the watermelon. Called store and they said they’d get me a new one. New one was smaller than the first one but I took it home. Well now I see it’s also spoiled and rotten with knats. It has leaked juice all over my dining room table and one of the chairs not happy at all.

I pick out watermelon for 50 years, The last two years a gotten horrible Watermelon 🍉 🚫🤮 from Sam Club the have right Strip color and yellow bottom right smell at stem and perfect thump sound. However, this year and last year the melon 🍈 have Hugh dry out crack inside and fruit does not taste good 😕 😢 The fruit is dry with bad taste. Sam Club need look for better farms in future there is something terrible wrong with there Watermelon 🍉 😑 I thinking more weather issues in region Watermelon grow in because tasted awful two year and 6 melons .

Every year i take a gamble hoping thats Sam's has resourced juicy firm SWEET WATERMELON. I GOT JUICY AND FIRM WHICH IS BETTER THAN PREVIOUS YEARS BUT I DID NOT GET SWEET, WATERMELON NEEDS TO BE ALL 3 JUICY, FIRM AND SWEET. VERY DISAPPOINTED BC WATERMELON IS MY ABSOLUTE FAVORITE FRUIT.

If you know how to pick a watermelon then you will surely enjoy it. I cut the watermelon and it lasted several days and was so sweet by day 5. I'm going to try my luck for a second one. Enough to share with friends and still have plenty for myself. A must buy this summer.

I bought this item On Monday and when I went to cut it open it was bad. I took a picture and I was afraid to eat it. So i just tossed it. Any chance I will be able to get a refund if i tossed the item? I didn't want to keep it in my home until tomorrow or when I would return to Sam's.

Definitely not seedless not even close to seedless, infact I think their was double what is in a seeded large watermelon lol. It was sweet but grainy and the seeds were so small it was a hassle to sit and take them out. Threw it in the trash so you got me Sam's but won't buy anymore watermelon ever from you.

I bought a watermelon 2 days ago. I am in northern Ohio. Yes I understand they are shipped in. DON'T WASTE YOUR HARD EARNED MONEY!!!! This watermelon is TERRIBLE!! It literally had no taste. No sweetness when right in the center. I wasted almost $7 on this. NEVER again will I buy a watermelon from Sams. We couldn't eat any of it. Yuck!! I just cut it up and took it out to the woods on our property and dumped the whole watermelon for the wild animals. Won't surprise me if they won't eat it either!!

Had a watermelon delivered yesterday. It was so heavy. It was $5.92. Great price. The problem with the watermelon was beyond ripe. To the point that none of it was edible. Dry in some places and in others it was like mush. Very disappointed. Flavor is so bad that I am throwing away all of it. Most of the vegetables I have delivered have been very good. Wasted $6.00