We bought one watermelon on my card that was not so good and one on my husband’s card to take to a party which was Excellent. It is just all in the choices we make.

Delicious watermelon. Nicely colored with a large ground spot (yellow spot where it laid on the ground). Very sweet, great price, and oh so good! We bought one and went back a couple days later to get another and will continue on that way till they run out.

Horrible. I bought many watermelons from Sam’s over the last few months and each one of them was inedible. They were all soft inside-likely frozen from the previous season. Please Sams Club, be sure to sell fresh watermelons. I’ve wasted so much money this year on bad watermelons from here.

The sample that I was given in store was delicious and refreshing. Sadly, the watermelon I chose wasn’t. When I cut into it there was a large hollow yellow-ish place. I tasted a piece that was far away from the hollow area and it was flavorless and unpleasant. The whole melon went into the trash. I would have returned it but I didn’t have time before leaving town.

I recently purchased three watermelons from Sam’s Club, and unfortunately, all three were rotten inside. This was very disappointing, especially because of the effort involved. Watermelons are heavy, I had to put them in the cart, load them into my car, carry them into my home, and only then discover that the fruit was not edible. I am 63 years old and live with rheumatoid arthritis, so that effort is not small for me. If the fruit had been good, it would have been worth it, but when all three were rotten inside, it left me frustrated and regretting the purchase. This is not the first time I’ve had this issue with fruit here, which makes me question whether the quality control process is being handled as carefully as it should.

Was told by a farmer that I had picked the perfect watermelon, “I guarantee this is a good one!” When I got it home, it was pink inside, not red, tasteless, truth is, I ate three bites of it and bagged it up and put it in the garbage, probably the worst tasting watermelon I’ve had in the last two years.

I’m very surprised to have purchased a half rotten Texas grown watermelon because they are always juicy and delicious. This time, I cut it open only to find that one half was rotten and the other half was juicy and delicious. The plums, on the other hand, are always rotten! I have purchased these plumbs approximately three different times throughout the last several years and the are always ROTTEN:/ I recommend buying the Texas grown watermelons because the one half rotten watermelon that I selected was just a fluke. I do not recommend the plums because they are always rotten like the Mexican imported watermelons which I don’t recommend buying.

This particular watermelon was soooo sweet and good. Before I finished cutting the watermelon in half, I could smell the fresh aroma and crispness of the watermelon. The color of the watermelon inside was beautifully red and firm. Not soft around the edges or in the middle like previous watermelons I've purchased in the past. If there's such a thing as perfect, this watermelon 🍉 was! And the price was perfect!!!!

I started to cut up the watermelon to put it in a fridge container. I sneaked a couple of bites and it was practically tasteless and the color was very light. I went ahead and put it all in the fridge thinking it might be better cold. I wound up throwing it all away.

This was the best watermelon! I'm never sure about how to buy a watermelon but I stuck to the things I've read -- brown stem, yellow side where it lay in the field and something I just read about -- wider spaced stripes. I made a really good choice.