Skip to Main Content
Sam's Club
Sam's Club
All Departments
All Services
Customer reviews for Wish-Bone Italian Dressing, 36 oz., 2 pk. for
Wish-Bone Italian Dressing, 36 oz., 2 pk.
4.7 out of 5 stars
stars
779 ratings234 reviews
  1. 5 stars87% (674)
  2. 4 stars6% (45)
  3. 3 stars2% (13)
  4. 2 stars1% (5)
  5. 1 star5% (42)
Sort by |
Showing 51-60 of 234 reviews
Mar 22, 2022
Reviewer name: Steve B
1 out of 5 stars
1 out of 5 stars review

Not what it used to be...

Back in the day this was the best salad dressing period. They have completely changed the recipe. It is now this thick, corn syrup infused mess. How I know it has changed is that there used to actually be a picture of a lemon on the label way back when and when you read the ingredients label there was lemon juice in the recipe. Now there is no mention of lemon juice at all. Could they experts over there dig out the old recipe from the 70's and just go back to it. It was so good back then you could drink it straight out of the glass bottle it came in. Now I wouldn't use it to marinate chicken. Please fix.

Review from wishbone.com
Helpful?75TRHYBU2FQX13586167769
reply from Customer Care

Hi Steve. Thanks for sharing your review of our Italian Dressing. We're sorry you're disappointed, and we're sharing your feedback with our team so your voice is heard. We understand taste preferences vary among our valued consumers and we appreciate knowing about yours. We hope you'll continue to choose some of our other Wish-Bone products and let us know what you think. Have a great day!

Aug 23, 2024
Reviewer name: Caroline
1 out of 5 stars
1 out of 5 stars review

Incredibly disappointed

This has been my all time favorite Italian dressing as a kid. Bought a bottle this week and immediately no. The flavor is gone, it tastes so watered down, and somehow it is sweet??? Terrible. Why ruin a great thing. Not buying again, bring the original back

Review from wishbone.com
Helpful?75TRHYBU2FQX13586167769
reply from Customer Care

Hi Caroline. Thanks for being a fan and for taking the time to share your review with us. We regret that this time, our Wishbone Italian Dressing let you down. We'll have our team look into this. We sincerely hope you will give us another try and share your thoughts on our other offerings. Have a wonderful day.

Apr 15, 2022
Reviewer name: jadeee
5 out of 5 stars
5 out of 5 stars review

literally life changing (not clickbait)

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] in my long life of 13 years i have never seen such a masterpiece. i never knew that a person could express art in the form of cooking—but oh, am i wrong. i would drink it out of the bottle if i could. no. i will. i WILL drink all of it in one moment. it would be my magnum opus; to bring the salad dressing to its full potential. people say beauty is in the eye of the beholder, but i will make it my mission to enlighten others about this miracle that you have created. thank you. though, it doesn't mean that i will stop there. i'm very glad that the creators behind this amazing brew of herbs and spices have been proud and tall. honestly, people would think that it is just good marketing; but i don't mind to compliment it. after all, it's always good to support others. - xoxo, your biggest fan

Review from wishbone.com
Helpful?75TRHYBU2FQX13586167769
Jul 19, 2024
Reviewer name: Teece
1 out of 5 stars
1 out of 5 stars review

Too sweet now

I grew up w this Italian salad dressing on the classic dinner salads my mother used to prepare and was so excited to find the not zesty version. I was very confused and disappointed about how overly sweet it is now. It’s almost like your Catalina dressing with some hints of the old style Italian. You should have made a different version with a different name but retained the original recipe as an option also. I hope you will offer the old recipe again, it was so good and no one needs more sugar in their diet!

Review from wishbone.com
Helpful?75TRHYBU2FQX13586167769
reply from Customer Care

Hi there. Thank you for taking the time to reach out to us. We're sorry to hear about your recent experience with our Wishbone Italian Dressing. Quality and satisfaction are our top priorities, and we're disappointed to learn that we fell short. We’ll address this issue with our quality control team to ensure improvements moving forward. Thank you for bringing this to our attention. We hope you have a great rest of your day!

Jul 9, 2023
Reviewer name: Ginny
1 out of 5 stars
1 out of 5 stars review

Wow what happened?

I just made a pasta salad with lots of spendy ingredients, only to have to throw it out it was so bad. Wayyy to sweet. What happened to the original recipe? I used to love this dressing in all salads and to use as a marinade. It's definitely changed, and not for the better. Time to change brands.

Review from wishbone.com
Helpful?75TRHYBU2FQX13586167769
reply from Customer Care

Hi there. Thanks for taking the time to share your review with us. We're sorry to hear our Wishbone Italian Dressing wasn't what you've come to expect. We'll make sure your feedback is shared with our team. Thanks again for reaching out to us.

Nov 14, 2024
Reviewer name: CMF2024
1 out of 5 stars
1 out of 5 stars review

Too Sweet Now- Inedible

This used to be my favorite dressing, but the recipe has changed and now its is very, very sweet. It tastes nothing like it used to! I would use this dressing in leafy salads, pasta salads, and it was a great marinade for proteins and vegetables. No longer! Why fix what was not broke? I am so disappointed.

Review from wishbone.com
Helpful?75TRHYBU2FQX13586167769
reply from Customer Care

Hi. Thank you for sharing your feedback with us. We're truly sorry to hear about your recent experience with our Wishbone Italian Dressing. Your satisfaction is important to us, and we're concerned about the quality issue you've encountered. We appreciate you bringing this to our attention and will investigate the matter. We hope your day is great.

Jan 16, 2021
Reviewer name: Vinegar Lover
5 out of 5 stars
5 out of 5 stars review

Don't listen to the haters

Wishbone Italian has been my go-to dressing for years. Sounds like the boomers writing about how there are too many herbs and spices are mad and can't seem to figure out how to make their 3 ingredient vinaigrette at home (oil, vinegar, lemon juice). Hey Wishbone, keep it up cause this Italian is at the top.

Review from wishbone.com
Helpful?75TRHYBU2FQX13586167769
Jun 15, 2022
Reviewer name: VGH5
1 out of 5 stars
1 out of 5 stars review

Ug, What Have They Done To The Recipe?

I just bought a bottle of this Itslian dressing to make the Salad Supreme pasta salad. It is sweet now and the taste is completely different…. and my pasta salad came out terrible. There’s no need for the extra sugar. Their old recipe was so much better with a richer, more in depth flavor. PLEASE PLEASE bring back the old recipe!!! Please please bring back the original Italian dressing!

Review from wishbone.com
Helpful?75TRHYBU2FQX13586167769
reply from Customer Care

Hi there. Thanks for your review of our Italian Dressing. We're sorry you did not enjoy the taste this time, and we're passing your valuable feedback along to our team. We hope you'll try some of our other Wish-Bone products and share your thoughts with us. Thanks again and have a great day!

Oct 31, 2019
Reviewer name: RickW
5 out of 5 stars
5 out of 5 stars review

Great Ranch!

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] wishbone ranch is a great tasting affordable ranch that everyone can enjoy! I am personally a fan of wishbone products and this ranch did not let me down. if you are looking for a great quality ranch Eddie reasonable price wishbone is your go-to brand. I recommend purchasing this product!

Review from wishbone.com
Helpful?75TRHYBU2FQX13586167769
Mar 29, 2023
Reviewer name: topaz7701
1 out of 5 stars
1 out of 5 stars review

Come on Guys!!!!

I always marinate my chicken breasts in Wishbone Italian.....But YUK! The recipe has changed and my chicken and salads don't taste the same. I'm so sad! Too sweet. Something was taken out of the recipe too, but I can't quite put my finger on what is missing. Please bring the original recipe back. Please and Thank you!!!

Review from wishbone.com
Helpful?75TRHYBU2FQX13586167769
reply from Customer Care

Hi there. Thank you for your review. We regret that this time our Wishbone Italian Dressing fell short for you. We'll make sure this is shared with our team. We hope you'll give us another chance and try some of our other products. Have a great day.