Best potato salad ever

No one guessed it wasn't! Oh My Goodness! I cooked a few extra potatoes, cut them up and added them, put in a fancy bowl and the entire bunch of it disappeared! It really does taste almost like my home made and there is now weird taste to it (like all others we've tried) Given the cost of ingredients these days - this is a tasty bargain!

I have never had potato salad this bad in my entire life. I'm over 50! It was like eating CANDIED POTATO SALAD. The sugar in it would send a diabetic to the hospital. All I could taste was sweet dressing on potatoes. What southerner would eat this CANDY potato salad? Disgusting, wish I could get a refund but I needed it for a gathering, so I WASHED OFF ALL THE DRESSING and added my own ingredients and mayonnaise. Still tasted sweet tho.

This is too sweet for my taste and as my title stated, it's nowhere near as good as Reser's Red Potato Salad which Sam's Club used to sell for years. Reser's is the best commercial potato salad you can buy. I will have to buy it elsewhere because this Member's Mark Southern Style is nasty in comparison.

I decided to try this because it had very good reviews and it's so cheap that you have almost nothing to lose by trying it. Now that I've tried it, I'm amazed. This is hands down, the very best potato salad that I've ever had. I hope my mom forgives me, but it's true. I'm stunned that a store bought potato salad is this awesome. It is a superior product.

This is very good potato salad. My family has a history of terrific homemade potato salad so store bought has tough skeptical expectation before it’s ever opened. This is good! It doesn’t have hard boiled eggs which I miss but that’s my only complaint

This is by far THE best store bought potato salad I have ever tasted. Getting to old to chop all the ingredients needed to make my own. I, like others, like mine with less mayonnaise, so I added more potatoes, my seasonings and a few other items and VOILA, homemade!! Seriously it is great on its own. Hope they keep this item in stock.

I used to buy this all the time. However, over at least a year ago they reformulated the product and its nothing like it used to be. I have tried it several times now since they changed it and its not something I can recommend anymore. I will not be buying it again.

Too much Mayonnaise.

This Member's Mark potato salad is delicious for store bought. Homemade is better but this is convenient. A warning: the container can be difficult to open and the corners are SHARP! I cut my hand on the corner- literally sliced off a deep chunk of skin. Ouch!!!