I bought 20# of St.Clair potato salad for a Baby Shower BBQ yesterday. I was counting on the good reviews I read here and I wasn't disappointed. I'm not exaggerating, this potato salad is delicious! The taste of the red onion and celery really comes through, it's creamy and has great flavor. I've done the painstaking work of making homemade potato salad in the past and it never tasted this good! My cousin said he doesn't even like potato salad but thought this one was awesome and asked me if I made it, and I wanted to say I did LOL. I'll be buying this again especially for family and work functions. You can't make 5# of potato salad for this price and that tastes this good!

The Member’s Mark potato salad is awful. The potatoes are hard and the taste cannot compare to the St. Claire potato salad. I realize the company is making it for Sam’s, but St. Claire certainly didn’t do Sam’s any justice in making this under the Member’s Mark name. They set Sam’s up for failure with this product. I highly recommend Sam’s go back to purchasing the St. Claire’s brand. I will NOT purchase the Member’s Mark potato salad again.

I was buying potato salad at a local deli and when they put my container on the counter, someone nocted it off and onto the floor. So they said they would get me another one. So while waiting, they brought a container from the kitchen and filled my to go replacement, I looked at the label on the container and it looked like it may have been from Sam's club. I was right. I found. it in the deli section and purchased 10 pounds. I have been addicted ever since.

The Member's Mark Southern Style is NO WHERE as good as the St.Clair Potato Salad. I even went on the St.Clair website which indicates that they collaborated with Sam's to develop the Southern Style product. To that I say...PLEASE RETHINK THIS DECISION & GO BACK TO THE OLD RECIPE. The the flavor is not as good and the potatoes are much harder.

We are not fans of this Member's Mark potato salad. This is the second time I purchased and returned this... once last year and again last week. I thought maybe I had gotten a bad batch previously - we really wanted to like this. The potatoes are over-cooked; carrots and celery are minimal and there is too much mayo/salad dressing. There is no comparing of this Member's Mark potato salad and the St Claire Redskin Potato Salad that Sam's used to carry. It was delicious, affordable and as close to homemade as you could get. Everyone loved it! PLEASE bring back the St Claire brand!!

This potato salad has miracle whip in it not mayonnaise. Please, please bring back the red potato salad made with mayonnaise. That was sooooooo much better! Potato salad should have potatos, mayo, tax bit of mustard, pickles red onion, celery, salt pepper and black olives if you like them.

This has to be one of the worst potato salads I've ever had. So sweet it was overbearing. Claims to have celery in it, but didn't see any at all. does have a couple of red specks in it. I assume is pepper? Very dry as well. Ive tried all three of Sam's potato salads now and this one was terrible! Ive added mayo, onion and celery to it, along with some dill pickle juice in an attempt to cut the sickening sweet. I don't know if that will make it palatable or it will just get tossed.

I bought this potato salad last week, everyone in my house hold agrees the potato salad is way too sweet. It taste like a Sweet Pickle Relish times 10. Besides that the size of the potatoes and and the vegetables are cut a nice size. I could not eat more than 2 bites of it.

I miss the red potato salad Sam's used to sell (not that loaded potato salad). This Southern potato salad is waaaayyyyy to sweet for my tastes. I had to add a little vinegar, but even then it's just too sweet overall. I won't be buying it again. Bring back the brand that started with R. Sorry, Member's Mark potato salad isn't as good.

I tried this product the beginning of September because I was having an event at the end of the month. I was very pleased with the taste and texture of the potato salad. I purchased 5 tunes for my event and everything had changed. It was horrible. I looked at it and could see the difference. I was telling everyone about how good the potato salad was but not anymore. I don't recommend at all. You had a good product and there was no reason to change it.