I wouldn’t serve this to a pack of wild dogs. The mayo they use is the consistency of whipped cream and there was wayyyyy too much sugar in this recipe overall. I threw the whole tub away after a small serving 🤮

I purchase this all the time, it is great for large parties, I boil more eggs and add a little mayo and relish and everyone loves it. Best potato salad I have found, and I am very picky about potato salad

It is horrible, bland and mashed! When will anyone in the market make a decent potato salad, we have to make it from scratch at home! The other potato salad you carry is as bad but with way to much add ins!

I bought this after reading all the great reviews, but I was very disappointed. I like my potato salad a bit sweet & tangy, but this is just flat and so sweet it's like dessert. You can't beat the price, but it was just too sweet for my taste.

I used to buy this potato salad at almost every trip to Sam's. A while back it changed in flavor and became overly creamy. No longer worth buying as I was throwing away most of a carton.

Sorry, but this was terrible. It's not just the amount of sweet, it's a texture thing also. It's sort of gooey. Will never buy again, does not taste like potatoes.

Not sure how this got over 4 stars!! It’s way too sweet. It’s like a mouthful of sugar. I had to doctor it up by adding mayo, sour cream and mustard. Anything to tone down the sweetness.

I normally buy small containers of deviled egg potato salad but when I seen this I said why not…I will defiantly buy again it has amazing flavor and is not mushy.

We love this potato salad. Its great as a side dish or even a snack. It has that great sweet relish flavor we love. Now that we found this potato salad...no more having to spend time making it. This is our go to. Who can beat the price.

We've bought this Potato salad numerous times and it has never disappointed us !!! It's a little too sweet for me but I find myself sneaking into the fridge for a spoonful lol. We have never hesitated to serve St.Clair's to anybody that comes over and wish we could take all the credit,well we do because we bought it LOL