Was skeptical to buy, but ended up being the best potato salad we've ever had. A little sweeter and creamier excellent product. Please don't change recipe.

this replaced the ST Clair potato salad they used to sell. not quite as good, but it's ok. just wish they would do better quality control. the last few tubs i have purchased have not been completely filled!

This is the best commercial potato salad on the market. I bought another brand at Costco and it was so horrible I had my brother feed it to the chickens. This tastes real home made and just like Mom used to make.

This is a SWEET tasting potato salad and tastes awful!! I couldn't even finish the container without adding mustard and another container of regular potato salad. Buyer beware, not your regular potato salad...

We used to like this and buy it every few weeks, but the last 2 batches have had hard Potatoes. Guess corporate wasn't happy with the profits and told the cooks to turn off the fire sooner. Won't be buying it any more. Was 4.5 stars-- now 2.

Great for a cookout and family gathering. There is no way one could make this much potato salad for this price. I highly recommend. Our family loves it.

Disappointing!!! .... waaaaay too much mayo... needs regular yellow mustard to really OPEN UP the taste. i grew up in the South and also am a Sheff so i know how it should taste. Great ingredients just marginal seasoning.

Chunky potatoes. Taste a little on the sweet side. Kind of reminded me of Walmart's Amish Potato Salad taste wise. This one has mustard in it though. Overall, I'd buy it again.

The wife loved the taste because it is sweet. I prefer a potato salad which doesn't overwhelm things you're eating it with. Reser's will always be my favorite commercial made.

This is the best store bought potato salad. The only issue is Sam's Club seems to never keep this stocked, only the Amish kind. Please keep this fully stocked.