Quick Fix

Better than my homemade!

Like many of us...I have gone from making homemade mashed potatoes to the convenience of prepared trays of mashed potatoes in the chilled section. While I have had really good success with Bob, unfortunately the M.M. brand is dry, bland, and filled with chunks of black "eyes" of potatoes. These are not creamy! I would plan on adding milk or cream if you buy them. I tried to add cheese and bacon to make a "Loaded" version...but there's no denying the base is dry and flavorless. A friend of mine adds a whole stick of butter to the tray and these definitely need it! I'll finish these once I dig out all the black eyes, add salt & pepper, milk or cream, and butter...but no way would I make this purchase again!

I have purchased these many times, and recently (in the last 5 months) they have been TERRIBLE! They taste like they've gone bad, almost like the milk or cream used in them is sour. They were extremely runny too. These are literally the worst mashed potatoes EVER!

Not sure what people have for taste buds leaving bad reviews. My wife is a steak and potato kind of gal and we'd make homemade mashed about every week. These pretty much taste the same if not better. And. Saves me about 40 minutes of messing around with potatoes. This also has fooled many family members including the mother in law. Can't go wrong here, especially for an event.

I decided to try these for the convenience, thinking they would be great for the holidays, since they had so many glowing reviews. Big mistake! I should have reversed the reviews and read the lowest ratings first. These potatoes were really awful -- watery, lumpy and waaay to salty. I actually threw them out, which I hate to do. Don't waste your money on this epic fail...

If you were looking for the Members Mark Homestyle mashed potatoes, these aren’t them!!! Those were the best, now these are what replaced them and they taste like instant or powdered potatoes!!! Not even close to good mashed potatoes. HUGE DISAPPOINTMENT. If you like instant, these will taste good, if you want real, mashed, buttered, milk, and great tasting, don’t bother!!! SORRY.

I love these mashed Potatoes, they taste just like homemade without having to spend 30 minutes of my busy schedule washing,peeling,cooking and then mashing them. It's 4 minutes in the microwave, 2 pats of sweet cream butter and bam homemade mashed potatoes that you & your family will love.

I bought these to save time making Thanksgiving dinner. I checked the label to ascertain that they were in fact REAL potatoes. It says they are. I checked the label again after I cooked them... they taste like potato flakes. They were utterly flavorless and even after I added garlic salt, asiago cheese and tons of Kerrygold butter they still didn't taste as good as regular mashed potatoes. I ended up tossing the bulk of them into the trash :(

I bought these via curbside pick up based on the photos and description. I have been buying it regularly because they were pretty good, but saw on the product packaging that they include a lot more than six ingredients. Time to update the photos and description for this product. Deceptive! Would have loved if this had only been six ingredients, but won't buy again.