What I thought was fat on the outside was tough, chewy gristle instead.

These steaks had zero flavor

Not as tender and flavorful as I was hoping.

Tender and packed with flavor

The steaks are amazing. I’ve gone back three times to buy more.

Sam’s Club stakes are fantastic - cuts are excellent and tender.

Full of gristle

Based on the reviews, the quality of these steaks must vary by region. The Prime New York Strips we've been getting at the Beavercreek Ohio location have been consistently excellent. The marbling has been really nice on these, and the taste has been great. We have been comparing these to the Prime New York Strips our local Costco sells, and we prefer the ones from Sam's. We've noticed a bit more waste on the Sam's Club ones, but Sam's isn't resorting to a mechanical tenderizer like our local Costco does. Overall, we're very pleased Sam's is selling prime steaks.

tough and tasteless

Love