They are tender and delicious. These steaks are cut the right thickness for how I like to cook them. To save money, I cut each steak in half to make 2 dinners. I can only afford these once in a while as I'm retired, disabled and 74.

The quality and tenderness of these steaks were excellent. We shared and made two meals out if them--was plenty. With minimal prep plus broiling/cooking time, adding salad and baked potatoes, we had a restaurant style dinner in a matter of minutes. The steaks were delicious--definitely preferred to eating out!

So tender and cooked to perfection.

Prime—other groceries don’t carry. If other groceries in the area carry prime meat it is unbelievably expensive and somehow just not as good. Sam’s meat is as good as the upscale butchers in the area. Great value, it’s priced below what other groceries charge when they have really great sales.

I buy Prime beef all the time . It always amazes me that grading beef is not the same as serving and eating the beef I have Had outstanding prime and I have also had Prime that had me mumbling HOW DID I PAY PRIME $$ for this terrible shoe leather. THIS steak was great not a 10 but I got my money worth on this cut . I just wish it was consistent in quality. Using the same providers is key I think staying with the same farm producer. is helpful.

We’ve acquired a taste for Prime steak since Sam’s started carrying it. We used to buy the Choice rib-eyes but the price got so high we decided to try the Prime strip steaks in the same price range. The trade -off is texture and flavor with smaller fat lines (Prime strip) vs. slightly lower price,(rib-eye) with bigger fat lines that can be tough on the edges. Prime strip wins!

We bought these labeled prime NY strips. They are members mark prime. That is not the same as USDA prime. I find this labeling misleading. The steaks were tough after cooking medium rare. Very disappointing. This is the second time I have paid for what I thought was premium beef and been disappointed.

This was supposed to be prime beef, but it was anything but prime. At best, it was basic USDA choice, and mediocre at that.

For the very first time the quality of the steaks was not up to par. I purchase their Prime Steak often and this time it was very chewy, stingy and gristly.

These steaks were HORRIBLE! They was more gristle than meat! Absolutely the worst I’ve ever had and I’ve eaten a lot of NYS steaks! I got them because there is nothing better than a NYS cooked outside on the grill while camping. I left them outside for the birds and raccoons. I spent my hard earned money on them to just throw them out!