I really was excited about getting a flavorful, flaky, crispy fish, but I cooked it on a sheet pan according to the box instructions, but the coating was greasy and mushy. The fish flavor on the inside was good, but they need to reevaluate the coating.

We have been buying these for a while in our local Sam's Club, but haven't been able to find them in several months. They make a great quick meal. I put them in my air fryer, then fix some sides or wrap them in a tortilla for a quick fish taco. Please, Sam's Club, make these available again in our local club.

I WOULD NOT HAVE GIVEN THIS EVEN ONE STAR! I finally tried the fish for dinner tonight and it was awful and gross!!! They smelled bad and tasted even worse. In addition, it is NOT “Beer Battered”. This product is beyond “tasting bad”; it tasted almost spoiled. The batter fell apart in my airfryer and they didn’t taste “cooked” after I air fried them for 25 minutes if not more. Sam’s needs to remove this item off the shelf before people get sick from eating them. I sent my feedback to Customer Service and would like to be refunded for this item for sure.

Purchased this on a whim, its hard to find a good frozen fish. This is a good product, very mild flavor. I cooked in the air fryer, which it turned out very nice. My only complaint is that it is breaded, but a lot of the breading had broken off of the fish and was in crumbles in the bag. Possibly a packaging issue or a handling issue through shipping and stocking. I may purchase again.

The first bag is fine. But the second and third bag since the Pandemic is not right. My kid got vomit and diarrear twice after eating this within a few hours. I suspect they used cod substitute which is ESCOLAR. ESCOLAR causes digestive distress for sensitive people. Be careful.

The batter had a good taste and the outside got crispy in the oven and by deep frying but the inside batter didn't cook all the way. The fish itself was bland, rubbery and had fatty strands running through the middle of half the pieces I tried. Plus, even with oven baking, pieces were super greasy.

We bought our first box last month and enjoyed every bite. Simple cooking instructions and came out of the oven perfect. Awesome beer batter!! The batter was crispy and the fish was flaky. On our second box and now a regular item on our family menu..

Well nothing like the original, they changed the color of the box, but does not taste good, real fishy taste does not taste like the beer battered original fish, Better then the blue box but first and last one I will buy. Why must they change a good thing

At one time, we gave these a 5-Star review. However, the last two boxes tasted awful. They tasted overly fishy and heavily breaded. Also, guar gum is now listed as an ingredient. We only buy wild caught fish and don't mind paying for quality. Unfortunately, the quality of these has drastically plummeted. These filets now contain large, inedible, hard, discolored chunks that can not be chewed. No longer light and flaky. Our little one used to look forward to eating these and just said, "YUCK", they're "Bisgusting". Sadly, we agree. Please steer clear. We can no longer recommend these.

I deep fried these. First batch I fried at 350°F... They were very brown, the insides were maybe 135°F. Second batch I cooked at 335°F for 3 minutes and pulled them out and then set the oil to 350°F.... Much better doing the double fry, just as crispy but the fish was hot and yummy