Taste, which is most important, was great. Not fishy. Beer flavor was not over-powering. I had a few left over and re-heated them and they were pretty much the same taste and consistency. They were a solid piece of fish, but tender. They were easy to prepare, first time in the oven with fries and the second time in the Air Fryer. I would purchase them again.

The new COD is TERRIBLE! My family loved the old COD, when grandkids knew I making it for dinner they came running! They do not like the new old and wants to know what Meme did to the fish! We would eat the old version at 3 to 4 times a month if not more. Please go back to the old version it was so much better than the new one!

The directions basically have us cook these small fish pieces into more than half the size they started. It turns the breading too dark of brown, the fish turns dry, and extremely overcooked. The fish itself is without flavor, but the breading is seasoned ok. I won't purchase this again.

I bought this item about 3 weeks ago but it came in a white box. My first batch was cooked in my airfryer under the recommended time and heat settings on the box. 2nd batch was in the air fryer again in the bake/roast setting (higher temp,450) and much longer time. With both cooking methods the fish was soggy as heck, the batter was falling apart and coming off the fish and the fish was bland and tasteless. An absolute waste of money. You can also fry it in a deep fryer but I don't have one and I know it's not going to come out much different. One of the worst products I have ever gotten from Sam's Club.

Very deceptive packaging reads "hand cut fillets" but these are NOT fillets at all but rather ground up fish parts pressed to resemble a fillet. They're actually expensive "fish sticks" and not very good ones at that. I can't believe Sam's Club allows their Members Mark logo on this packaging. Try them and I can guarantee you'll return them like I did.

I bought these as they were sampling them in March, 2022. They were really good and we had them for dinner a few times. I had forgotten about them until a few weeks ago and got them again. This time they were inconsistent sizes so they did not cook evenly. But the ones that were cooked were still very good.

These are delicious and easy to heat up a few pieces in a toaster oven which is perfect for a single person living alone. I've made a quick fish sandwich for lunch and made rice and vegetables to go with them for dinner. Filets are moist and tasty.

Excellent fish filets. Great taste and texture.

They bake well on an air fryer

Did not like it. Too little fish with lots batter.