What Happened? They were excellent at one time. No more, never more. Was it the price increase in eggs that killed the taste and consistency? Probably. This tastes too sweet and fake. There is not much of a pumpkin taste either. I will be baking my own pies. I will skip the membership too.

Reasonably priced for a Thanksgiving holiday staple.

We love this pie and you can’t begin to make it for that

Great price, flavor and value

The best pie!! Should have bought more. This pie was gone in an instant. So sad, no left overs.

Delicious pie and you can't make it at home for the price.

The pie was good, but it wasn’t cooked well enough to my liking.

Was not a fan. It was bland and wasn't a fan of the texture.

Best pie around, good taste

This piecwas not as good as prior year’s pumpkin pies. Crust was very thick and tasted bad.