Skip to Main Content
Sams Club
Sams Club
Customer reviews for Member's Mark 12" Pumpkin Pie, 58 oz. for
Member's Mark 12" Pumpkin Pie, 58 oz.
4.6 out of 5 stars
stars7,209 ratings1,825 reviews
  1. 5 stars78% (5,640)
  2. 4 stars10% (692)
  3. 3 stars6% (399)
  4. 2 stars3% (221)
  5. 1 star4% (257)
Write a review

Customer photos

Sort by |
Showing 551-560 of 1,825 reviews
Dec 12, 2023
Jim
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Outstanding Pie

The quality of the pie is excellent. Outstanding Pie for large gatherings as it provides more than twice as many servings as an 8" pie and serves almost 50% more people than a 10" pie.

Helpful?5FLBO6XYNFY613567251796
Dec 17, 2024
frostyva
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

A really good pumpkin pie for the price

The family all enjoyed the pumpkin pie from Sam’s. It was bigger than a supermarket pie at a lower price. I recommend eating with a dollop of whipped cream.

Helpful?5FLBO6XYNFY613567251796
Dec 6, 2024
HappyGirl
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Great pumpkin pie

We received this free via a promotion. I have to admit, we were pleasantly surprised by the quality of this pie. The crust was flaky and delicious. We would buy this again.

Helpful?5FLBO6XYNFY613567251796
Nov 20, 2024
Directionboy1
3 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

You Get What You Pay For Pumpkin Pie

The Pumpkin pie was edible. The crust was the most challenging. If it wasn't for the whipped topping I believe it would have gone to waste. Even the filling was lacking. Perhaps a bit more but nutmeg.

Helpful?5FLBO6XYNFY613567251796
Oct 11, 2023
Shannie
2 out of 5 stars review

Not the same as precious years...

I love pumpkin pie, and I have always loved the one from Sam's club. I picked one up tonight and was so disappointed. It is horrible. The crust is so hard, I can barely break through it with my fork. And the flavoring of the filling is horrible. I am so glad I tried this before taking it to my mother's on Thanksgiving as usual. This will not be purchased again, and this will definitely not be a Thanksgiving dessert. Such a dissappointment. Why change a good thing???

Helpful?5FLBO6XYNFY613567251796
Nov 20, 2023
Brandi
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Yum

Yummy and not too sweet.

Helpful?5FLBO6XYNFY613567251796
Dec 13, 2024
Pat R
1 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Not At All A Fan

These were very large pies at a very good price and i thought it was worth saving time to buy these. Who can screw up a pumpkin pie? Sam's can! Only overly sweet pumpkin flavor with no spices. I couldnt even choke down a half piece of it. My family made sure to let me know it wasn't homemade and to not do that again! Lesson learned. I will say their Honeycrisp Apple pies are absolutely delicious and I would definitely eat again - however I don't feel I could spend that kind of money on 1 pie. For that kind of money I would definitely make it at home.

Helpful?5FLBO6XYNFY613567251796
Nov 5, 2023
Bring the Old Recipe Back
1 out of 5 stars review

Still Looking for the Great Pumpkin

Really gone down hill from previous years. The pumpkin is very light in color, and the taste is just so so. Not the good pumpkin you used to have in your pies. What has changed? Almost tastes and looks like it has fillers in it to make it stretch further. Hmmm

Helpful?5FLBO6XYNFY613567251796
Oct 29, 2023
Erin
1 out of 5 stars review

Bring back the old recipe

My family was so disappointed with this pie. There wasn't one of us that liked it and my husband eats everything. The pie had a weird texture and a overly strong spice taste. The crust was hard and not flaky at all. Sam's use to have one of the best pumpkin pies but not anymore. I wish Sam's would bring back the old recipe!

Helpful?5FLBO6XYNFY613567251796
Nov 18, 2022
Paul
3 out of 5 stars review

Not good anymore

This used to be the best premade pumpkin pie out there. However, I bought one this year and it was dry and tasted like cardboard. I thought maybe it was a fluke, but my mom said the same thing about one she purchased three states away. It was so bad that I returned it. The lady at customer service said there had been a lot of complaints about the pumpkin pie, and that she personally had experienced the change in quality. She suspected maybe they changed the recipe from previous years. It's really disappointing because I always looked forward to Sam's pumpkin pie..

Helpful?5FLBO6XYNFY613567251796