We really didn't think this pumpkin pie would be that good for the price. Wrong! It was delicious! We had a slice every evening till it was gone.

I received a Pumpkin Pie that was 3 day prior to the expiration date. Don’t sell me any food item not fresh, if your food isn’t fully fresh, within months of its expiration date then don’t sell it to me or any other customer for that matter!

We got this pie as a birthday treat and as a holiday treat. We have eaten for breakfast, for a snack, and after dinner - Had one piece with melted chocolate. Very tasty - great value! :)

Always bought these pumpkin pies for holidays. This year something changed. Color was off and tasted nothing like pumpkin. Very gluey consistancy . No one liked it! Cheaper ingredients????

I was so excited when I saw the pumpkin pie I didn't even look at the ingredients. You can forget about a flaky crust on this pie. The crust is thick, mushy in some places, hard in others.

I bought a pumpkin pie for Thanksgiving because you just can't beat the price. It wasn't good. Not the same recipe as last year. Very disappointed. Wont be buying again.

What Happened? They were excellent at one time. No more, never more. Was it the price increase in eggs that killed the taste and consistency? Probably. This tastes too sweet and fake. There is not much of a pumpkin taste either. I will be baking my own pies. I will skip the membership too.

This is the best pumpkin pie EVER. Better than homemade and offered at a great price. When I'm in the store picking out a pie to buy I have add so many conversations with others that are repeat buyers or ask if they are good. I'm always glad to see when these show up for purchase. I would buy year round if available.

Bought this hoping to enjoy a big pumpkin pie. Had a slice and it was so bland. Too much milk, not enough pumpkin, not enough spices in their recipe . The crust was bland and not flaky. I threw it away and had to buy a replacement pie from another grocery store.

this is the first pumpkinpir where the crust is thin, fully baked, and not raw on the bottom. i dont know if the one i bought is a fluke, but it is the best pie Sam's has ever sold. maybe a mistake nut a good one. this pie is theb one you can even eat ALL of t.