These made my dog sick and gave her fishy belches after a week. They are not soft either. The bag is in the trash.

I’ve used this for my dogs hips and joints and it does help. Our dogs are family members so we care about their hip and joint health!

This product works very well for my girls. And every other day per the instructions is a perfect dose. Much more active

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] The dogs like this hip and *****. Others I have to smear with peanut butter for them to take it.

After about a month on these my dog started throwing up and became very lethargic. I stopped giving her them and she recovered.

These are much harder than I thought. You can tell my dogs have to really chew down on them. But overall, they seem to enjoy them and it seems to be helping both my dogs.

I had to order this online and pay shipping because I can't find it in the clubs anymore. The product seems to be drier/stale but I'm still using it. Would rate higher if service and quality were better.

I was trying the product for my aged small dog. I thought it would be a good idea to try to benefit her elderly joints. My problem is my dog won't eat the item, even when I break it into pieces or mix it with other food or treats

These are very hard and my small dogs will not eat them as a treat or in their food. I tried cutting them into small bites and adding to their food but they are even hard to cut up with a knife. I would not buy again.

I bought vitamins that where a lot more expensive that hadn't worked for my dog. Just a few days on these wow she is up and moving like she did a year or two ago. They work and are affordable plus she loves them.