[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] These were harder and crumblier than I expected. The ingredients are decent, though I'm not sure why dog treats need added sugar. My dogs ate them, but they didn't seem to love them or get particularly excited when I brought them out. Overall, they're okay—I'd consider buying them again if my dogs had enjoyed them more.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Bailey, my Doberman will do anything for just one of these! She's motivated to be a good girl and enjoys treat time even more now. I have also used these for car training and she's very encouraged to be a good girl while riding in my car as she knows this is her reward. I like the texture and look of these Milk Bone Marrow snacks. They have a nice aroma and contain 12% protein. Bailey loves snacks that are high in protein. They're made with real bone marrow and help keep her bones and teeth, strong and healthy. They also aid in cleaning her teeth and she loves these things. I love their products and they're always priced affordably. I love this big jar, especially for the price. They're crunchy and great for every day snacking and training!

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] My husky absolutely loves these treats, very affordable for the amount that are in there and they are a perfect size to take on with the long walks. I like this container, the screw on lid keeps treats fresh and very versatile to reuse after treats are gone. I believe chewing harder things it does clean their teeth, these treats are crunchy and flavorful. Feel good giving these because they're from a trusted brand, great quality, and my husky enjoy them without any issues . Overall, these are delicious, convenient, and well-loved treats that makes training and snack time a fun experience for my dog!

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] My dog, Garrison, is the bestest boy. He always deserves a good treat especially with his 13th birthday creeping up on us(every day is an excuse for a treat) Garrison is a pug and English bulldog mix so he is also a beefy boy, at almost 50lbs, so he loves bigger treats. These are the perfect size for him because he still gets a few chews out of them. I love the resealable container they come in so they can maintain freshness(not that they will last long) Garrison gives these 2 paws up and wants to know when it's treat time again?!

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] All 4 dogs love these tasty Milk Bone Maro Snacks. They are just the right size for a quick treat and the dogs are ready to pull out all of their best tricks to get one. They are a good price for what you get as well!

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] The milk bone maro snacks are a great size for quick treats! My dogs are a German Shepherd and a Poodle so the large size are the perfect bites for them. My dogs scarfed these up fast! I love the large value size container.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] this is perfect for my dog. She's often very picky, but with these, she literally smelt it and was getting so excited about it. my dog really liked it and she enjoyed it and finished the whole treat.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Nice size container good packaging not too much crumbs. My dog pretty much does not leave anything. He likes it a lot. It does smell good. That's the most important thing is that my dog likes the snacks

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] My dog loves these treats. They are a little messy but it's dry so nothing is left behind when the dog is done. They are in a nice storage container helping to extend the shelf life. They are crunchy but not too hard, my dog is a senior and these aren't too hard for him.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] My dogs love these! The jar is huge and it will last them quite a while. I love the size of these treats because they're not too small for my giant dog, but also perfectly sized for my smaller dog. I also love how easy it is to giveas many as I want to each dog. They seem to love the flavor and that's the most important thing for me. Such a good value!