My dog absolutely loves these! We have been buying them for her since she was a year old. We started at paying 5.99 for them for a very long time now, for years! Now they keep raising the price every time I buy them, $1 here then up a $ the next month. They’re up to 15.99. So we need to move on and find something a little bit cheaper. I know she misses them, we tell her “would you like a little Redbone” and she goes nuts. Wish me luck and find something just as good and a affordable price. SAD!!😢

I purchase these treats on the regular. My dog (Boston Terrier) loves them and often times, when she doesn't want to eat her food, we'll crumble up about half of one of these treats and she eats like she's supposed to. We also give a treat at night and can tell she looks forward to having one.

My dog absolutely loves these. He is VERY fussy. When IAMS stopped selling the ones he was on for 5 years, I didn’t think I would find another one he would like. He would not eat any other treat offered to him. I went through at least 13 kinds trying to find another one he liked and this was it

This is such a bargain compared to what they cost elsewhere. You would be nuts not to buy this from Sam's. Our older dog loves these so much she will go outside to squat just so she can come back inside and get a 'treat'. She will repeat this routine just so she can get more!!!! "You mean, if I go outside and 'squat' I can come back in and get a treat" is her motto!

While I cannot personally verify that this is a delicious treat for pups, I can unequivocally confirm that Toto loves them. He has other treats, but usually turns his nose up at them until I reach into this jar and he enthusiastically removes them from my outstretched hand. So I’m guessing other dogs would react in a similar way.

These soft and chewy treats smell very good and our dog loves them. She will eat as many as you give her so I know she thinks there tasty and delicious. There made with real beef and contain 12 vitamins and minerals to help your dog stay healthy and happy.

My dogs all love these! They are pretty picky when it comes to their snacks and this one is both a snack and a treat used for training! My new go to. We also buy more expensive all natural stuff but these come in handy when we need to switch it up. These are easily broken into smaller pieces, which is great for my small breed dogs!

With 8 dogs and senior ones to boot, having the large size is so convenient. These are easy on old dog's teeth and they love both flavors. Great as a training snack for young dogs, too because they can be broken apart and fed in pieces. All around a GREAT buy!

I have a very fussy little dog and he likes only one kind of treat that costs way too much. All the other dogs I have had in the past loved Milk-Bones but Otis could not chew them so when I saw Soft Chewy from Milk-Bone I jumped at it and Otis loves them. It is the first treat that was good for him that he likes. His best friend Sally loves them but I have to break them up for her but the she too loves them.

Bought these hoping to have a treat with less fat then Pupperoni treats. Unfortunately our little dog did not care for them so we were stuck with two large jars of these treats. Gave them to a relative with four small breed dogs. Three of the four liked them but our dogs brother would not eat them either. The two dogs that would not eat them have great sense of smell but I do not know if they were picky because of that or not.