My dpgs prefer the chicken treats, but they like the beef as well. They stay soft through the bottom of the jar if you get out the treats and close the container again.

Although my dogs loved it first day, they have stopped wanting it second day. Now they just roll their eyes, I think. Not a bad product, I think my dogs are picky eaters.

My husband went to Sam’s in our neighborhood & they sold out. We found them online, then waited til cyber Monday & bought them at a better price!!!!!!

Schnauzer-Yorkie mix LOVES these! She has threatened my life the only time we came close to running out. Never again will I make that mistake—always an extra in the pantry from now on!

Our older hound dog wasn’t able to chew hard dog biscuits. Now, he eagerly watches for us to open his container of Soft & Chewy treats. They have made a big difference in his life!

My four-legged babies love the milk bones and I highly recommend them for the price it’s not a bad deal at all and they’re very soft and chewy for them specially if they’re older dogs

My two older granddogs love the soft beef and chicken flavors. I love the look on their faces when they get these treats. The 37 oz size and prices are great. I also love being able to ship to them.

Great value for all you get. Half the amount you get at Sam's purchased at Walmart will cost you the same price if not a little more than these purchased at Sam's. Plus, my dogs love these things

The plastic container packaging definitely helps minimize mess and keeps pests away if uou have to keep these treats in your garage . My pitbull/mastiff mix loves these treats

OMG! My Pooch LOVES these! She is 15 and pretty picky and I just recently tried them for her since they are a soft treat. They smell like beef jerky coming out of the canister and are about 3" long. Will be buying again!