I'm honestly not sure what to rate these. My dogs LOVE them and we've purchased the for years. However, the new batch we just got seems a bit different. It's lighter in color and is very, very moist. They're normally pretty soft - but this is different. Our youngest dog actually spit it out this morning when I gave out treats. She never does that. Then, a few hours after that, she started vomiting?! Maybe it's all a coincidence, but now I need to keep an eye on her to see if it happens again.

Great Product!! My Doss Love them!!

Pup loves these. He's little, so I break them in half for him

The dog loves them. Plus they are a good buy.

Tasty snacks for my dogs. They love them & there soft.

Sparkle loves them great price.

They were not very soft for my rote

my two dogs really like Soft and Chewy. It's soft like a Pupperoni so my older dog likes it alot.

my dogs love them very good product.

Small soft chew that our dogs love.