As with other Sam’s brand knock-offs, this misses the mark. Even if we had never experienced the national brand it mimics, we would never had liked this product. Unpleasant flavor. Not what you want when snacking.

I have always bought MM extra large peanuts but lately they have been overcooked and contain some so hard they almost broke my tooth. Please go back to the way they were or list the Planters brand of same peanuts for sale.

I use to enjoy this peanuts. Love the size and taste. Now there is no salt on these nuts. The salt on these nuts is what gave them there flavor. Bring back the salt.

An occasional large peanuts ..mostly average or small rather dry peanuts..becoming less impressed by Members Mark products..spend a bit more get Planters

Just bought these. I must say I was expecting more snap. The Virginia pnuts I've had in the past were well known for their crispness. These are, well, just peanuts. They have good flavor but if you're looking for that snap, look elsewhere. These are also small as VPs go, certainly not 'Extra Large' as the can says. Won't buy again.

We've bought a few of these and definitely like them most of the time. Too often they're roasted to the point of almost being burned and will leave a bitter taste. Also, these aren't really 'extra large' peanuts, they're more like regular sized. The average size is about 5/8 inch when compared to actual extra large size of an average of 7/8 to 1 inch. Unfortunately, the method used to determine what size a peanut is - uses a screen to see which ones will fall through. So, if they're of a certain diameter they can still be called 'Extra Large' - by the US Govt, but not in my book. They're still good, but just be ready for less than expected.

Tasted terrible, like old peanut oil. The nuts appear dark and dull in color. The product description says "Expertly roasted to achieve the right balance of crunch and flavor", but again I would say these nuts are dull instead of crunchy and tasted old and dull.

You wouldn't think that peanuts could taste so different, but they do. The quality of the Sam's product just is not in the same league as the Planter's peanuts. They don't seem as fresh and just seem to have a different finish in the mouth. I really miss Sam's club selling planters peanuts in this kind of container.

Yet another Member's Mark product that misses the mark. The Planter's brand was superior in taste and appearance, yet inexplicably, Sam's Club replaced them with these. The canister I received is slightly overroasted, with a darker color and harder texture than optimally cooked ones would be.

In recent months both online and in store these have been over roasted. They are very dark and taste burnt. I used to order multiple containers monthly and would love to order more but have become skeptical of them. Please fix the problem as others have had similar comments.