The recipe for these have changed for reasons unknown. The previous treats worked so well that our vet was amazed at the improvement of our pup's gum and teeth health. The last couple of bags have looked and smelled different. Our dog has vomited several times after eating the new formula before we realized this was the cause.

I have been giving these to my dog since she was about a year old. I didn't understand the importance of dog's dental care but with these it takes the guess work out of it. I've given her other brands but this brand is the only one she takes her time to chew which has definitely cleaned her teeth.

Do not buy these!!!! BOTH of my senior dogs had severe watery diarrhea and vomiting after having these! After they became sick I came to the review section and see other dogs have become ill as well. Sam’s Club should have pulled these off the shelves but continue to sell them despite several reviews alerting them that they are making dogs sick. People trust you to put good products out for their families and pets-Do better!

Please do not buy these so-called treats! I gave one to my small dog and he puked up the pieces then had diarrhea. The ingredients are not digestible. My vet said she has seen many dogs of various sizes suffering from ingesting this specific product! Sam’s needs to pull it off the shelf! I do NOT RECOMMEND!!

I have used this product for years, when it was white and did not have an odor. It worked well. I was disappointed when it seemed to be discontinued. The last package product was light brown and has an unpleasant odor,. Why was the formula changed, who decided it, and is there any oversight and review?

My pups let me know it’s time every night for their treat when it gets dark. They keep reminding me until I get up and break one in half for each of them. They absolutely love them. I keep an extra bag on hand all the time to insure I never run out!!

Returning them. They made my dog sick.

Recipe recently changed with no notice on the package. I thought I received a spoiled bag due to the brown, greasy appearance. My dog isn’t interested in the new version. I returned the bag and I wont continue buying them.

Unfortunately I cannot recommend these. I bought them for my Australian Shepherd and she liked them but they made her sick and she vomited the rest of the day. I thought she just had a sensitive stomach. I threw the rest of the chews away. A year later I purchased them again now for my mixed breed dog. He too liked them but became sick to his stomach and vomited. Threw those chews away now. Never again.

My six-year-old Boxer has one of these every day and he is the only Boxer I’ve had that has never had to have his teeth cleaned