Ordered online-don't know if it was old stock or what but "mealy" and the dogs barely would touch it-even with added canned food-the doves and birds wouldn't even eat all the leftovers. Didn't cause any gut upsets though-they just hated it-waste of my money

Great dog food. Been feeding Member's Mark Exceed dry dog food since the "boys" were pups. We gave them the puppy food and then at a year transitioned to this. They love it. Their coats are shiny and they really do not poop as much as if you buy cheap dog food with lots of fillers. We highly recommend Member's Mark Exceed Dog Food. We go thru about a bag every 10 days. We feed three dogs.

I am so happy to see that Sam's club brand is trying to compete or exceed the quality of ingredients of the name brand food types and trying to keeps it's customer's pocket book in mind. Large Lab loves the food and I love the new ingredients. I'm a former nutro, natural choice and then Purina customer due to rising costs for good food and a larger family to feed. Now it's going to be the Member's Mark Exceed brand for our family pet.

My dogs love this food but have a hard time chewing it. It is to hard and the shape of the kibble is to round. Would love to continue to buy it, but it just does not work for my dogs. I have 6 cavalier King Charles, so it may be fine for bigger dogs, just did not work with mine..

This is probably one of the best-priced foods on the market that doesn't use corn as a main ingredient. Our dogs have all liked it and I like that the pieces are small enough to fit inside one of their toys to give them something to do if I have to be away for a long while. I also love the zip-to-close top. One possible deficiency in the formula - Our older dog has developed brittle nails and both dogs have developed fairly dry, dull coats. We are now supplementing with fish oil, which seems to be creating an improvement. This was our first experience ordering online for home delivery. I was happy to see that the bag came wrapped inside a silver shipping pouch, which protected it from damage on the way. When I opened the pouch, I happened to be looking at the bottom of the bag - Otherwise I wouldn't have noticed that the bottom seal wasn't fully sealed. There was about a 1.5" gap on each end that was open. The seam had been folded over it, so no food had fallen out and I can assume nothing had gotten in. We're feeding it right away to prevent it from going stale or having any other issues. I contacted Sam's Club about this but got no response. We bought another bag in-store a few days later "just in case," and that one was fully sealed, so this must have been either a factory issue or it might have been cause by being tossed around in shipping, forcing air out through weak points in the seal. Anyway, just something to check, particularly if you're not going to use it up quickly. I still recommend the product.

Recently adopted this 7 yr old big boy to his “Forever Hone”, he had been eating similar food from Trader Joe's and found this to be much greater value and he had a very smooth transition, not the typical issues in diet/food changes. The ingredients are almost identical to his old food and yet saving 40% on the cost now and big boy loves it

I am not a big fan of pet food buying but my wife is. She told me this is what to get from now on and I will do until she tells me otherwise. We have tried a few but she is definitely happy with this brand of pet food. Judging from the way the dog eats it, he prefers it as well.

Love this product for our labs. Our vet told us when we were using Beneful that it was the equivalent of feeding our dogs McDonald's and doughnuts every day. Basically, junk food and fillers. We searched for a healthier alternative and found that this product was highly rated for pet nutrition.

Excellent food for my three dogs. 5 Stars for the food and 1 star for the delivery. I've been using the dog food for a year and decided to try having it sent to my house directly. Two months now doing that ant both times, the bag was ripped open. Easy to put into another container, but I shouldn't have to do that.

I like that it is Made with real chicken, and rice and contains essential vitamins and nutrients with No added fillers or artificial preservatives, I was feeding my boys Beneful however, after reviewing the ingredients the Members Mark is much better