Skip to Main Content
Sam's Club
Sam's Club
All Departments
All Services
Customer reviews for Member's Mark Almond Butter, 24 oz. for
Member's Mark Almond Butter, 24 oz.
4.6 out of 5 stars
stars
3,800 ratings1,240 reviews
  1. 5 stars79% (2,986)
  2. 4 stars10% (370)
  3. 3 stars5% (178)
  4. 2 stars3% (104)
  5. 1 star4% (162)

Member photos

  • +7 images
Sort by |
Showing 1,121-1,130 of 1,240 reviews
Apr 10, 2024
Dee
3 out of 5 stars review

Oil Separation Fix

I haven't tried this almond butter yet, so I can't attest to the flavor. To fix the oil separation issue, store the jar upside down so that the oil collects on the bottom and you can just eat what's on the top. It also makes it easier and less messy when you have to stir. Hope this helps. I look forward to trying this almond butter and will leave a new review after doing so.

Helpful?0UOSTOIO1HGR7874214200
Jan 31, 2019
DebbieD
5 out of 5 stars review

We like it

This tasted like the roasted salted almonds in the blue bag, not the bland white-label almond butter. We like that it's a little salty - makes a great compliment to apples or bananas. It's not hydrogenated, so the oil and almond paste separate. I pour off the oil, scoop all the paste into a mixing bowl, and start mixing with a large spoon. I add oil back in to my desired consistency and toss what I don't use. Not that hard!

Helpful?0UOSTOIO1HGR7874214200
Jan 16, 2024
MK
1 out of 5 stars review

ONE BAD JAR

ONE of the several jars I purchased is BAD; when I opened it this morning, it was HARD as a rock and could not stir it at all. I buy this particular product often and have never had this issue before. Additionally, it appears it is NOT returnable; however, a FULL REFUND is in order. MK

Helpful?0UOSTOIO1HGR7874214200
Jan 26, 2021
Kim
5 out of 5 stars review

Good almond butter and a few hints

This does have a lot of oil that sits on the too. What I do is pour about 1/2 off into a jar and use it for cooking/baking. I always add about 2 tsp raw sugar and a little salt. What I do to mix it up is use a butter knife to loosen then I use the dough hook on my hand mixer to mix it through. The best thing to do is use the mixer on low/Med (depending on the strength of your mixer) and mix in the jar a little of the way and work my way down to the bottom. After doing this I don’t have to remix when I use it later. BESURE to hold on to the jar. As you mix it you may want to add some of the oil back to get the consistently that you like.

Helpful?0UOSTOIO1HGR7874214200
Jun 20, 2020
Stephen
2 out of 5 stars review

Messy!

This almond butter has good taste, but suffers from having far too much liquid content. Even when properly stirred, it runs everywhere. Using it with a sandwich makes for a frustrating experience as it runs all over your hands and plate, slipping out of your sandwich. There has to be a way make it not so runny. The taste is there. Consistency, not so much.

Helpful?0UOSTOIO1HGR7874214200
Jun 6, 2025
Me
4 out of 5 stars review

Tastes so good! Not smooth or thick, but delicious

The best tasting & made with real ingredients. Roasted almonds & salt only. It is not smooth or thick. It has a grainy texture & is too thin to make a sandwich, however, it is delicious with Greek yogurt & fruit. It needs to be mixed well because the oil separates. The only brand that does not have a bunch of added oils. Please sell these at the store again. Shipping only is a pain because I'm in FL & it is so terribly hot to ship food items for several months.

Helpful?0UOSTOIO1HGR7874214200
Jun 26, 2019
Husker
1 out of 5 stars review

too much liquid

I bouth this last week, and it has too much liquid (oil?) to the point that it is impossible to spread it on a bread ! I was trying to make an almond butter and banana sandwich, but this stuff just went through the bread strait to the plate :( despite the fact that I mixed it after opening for about 5 min or so.

Helpful?0UOSTOIO1HGR7874214200
Jan 30, 2022
DG5
5 out of 5 stars review

Best Almond butter

My knees nearly buckled after my first taste. I've tried a few different brands over the years some of them perhaps are store brands I don't remember the names but I know they were not close to how good this tastes. I made my own repurchase list & this is the first item I added.

Helpful?0UOSTOIO1HGR7874214200
Oct 6, 2023
Franki
5 out of 5 stars review

No longer sold in store at my location

So I ordered 3 and had it shipped. Worst idea ever. One of them busted open, there wasn't any packing cushions to keep them from rolling around. Great almond butter and the only one affordable without all the additional additives. Why they won't sell it in store anymore is beyond me.

Helpful?0UOSTOIO1HGR7874214200
Jun 18, 2020
YIA YIA
2 out of 5 stars review

Half of jar is oil

When you open a jar it is half oil. I mixed oil into "butter" and it was like soup. I could litterally pour it out of the jar like pancake batter. The second jar I poured off the oil and only had 1/2 a jar of butter. Mixed up butter without oil and it was better but not at all like a nut butter. When I buy a jar of almond butter I expect to get a ful jar of butter not oil. If you mix the oil in llike it says on the jar you can't even keep it on a piece of toast, it just runs off. And yes, i have mixed it all, even from the bottom. I do however like that it is just almonds and salt with no additives and no sugar. Don't think they look at these reviews, they haven't fixed the problem in years.

Helpful?0UOSTOIO1HGR7874214200