We've been buying this for years and never had a problem. Recently they changed the formula and now it's terrible. It's a darker color, smells different and worst of all it no longer clumps like it used to. I have trouble scooping now because it breaks apart so easily. We will no longer be purchasing this product.

Somewhere over the past year they changed the formulation of this litter. It now is so full of dust that my cat leaves a trail all over the house when she exits the cat potty. The litter is a great value compared to other brands, but I'm not sure all the dust makes it worth the savings.

I love the price of this cat litter. I can spend $23 on two buckets of this cat litter and it will last all month. When I first started using it I really liked it. If I could find another cat litter around the same price I would switch. This cat litter is so very dusty. Also it sticks to the bottom like cement. I have to use a metal spoon to scrape it before I use the plastic scooper.

I thought it would live up to its claim of being "scoopable," but it didn't. The clumping breaks apart when scooped, so you end up with stinking powder spreading all over the litter box. Occasionally, there might be a clump here and there, but you can tell there is either a mixing defect or they are cutting corners. It's not worth the box it came in with.

With 4 cats it gets expensive to buy cat litter. I recently purchased Sam's club brand Member Mark. This litter was better than the ones I was previously bought that cost twice as much. Dust was minimal, it clumped, and odor was controlled. I will not go back to the higher price brands.

I have bought this and have used for 3 months. We enjoy the price, but have noticed that the amount of dust that has accumulated in the cat room is absolutely HORRIBLE. The room has been a cat room since we moved into the house. The number of cats and boxes have remained the same, yet the dust on the furniture is so bad. I was trying to buy an air purifier, to run in their and my husband said it has only gotten this bad since we changed to Member's Mark. So I guess paying more will be cheaper on my cleaning expense?

I have been buying this product for quite a while and with good results. Recent purchase are not the same in quality. I will not buy this product again since last few containers did not clump. Considering this was my go to product for cat boxes, now have to buy other products for this purpose since what ever change was done made this scoopable litter worthless

We will no longer be buying this product the last 2 containers no longer clump the litter together. The litter box smells to high heaven because the litter will not clump where the cats do their business and because it will NOT CLUMP we can not effectively remove the used litter. It is really too bad because it was a great product at a great price before the last 2 tubs. But the NEW IMPROVED version is worse that the old version.

The clumps do not stay together. It breaks apart into tiny bits and contaminates the box with lingering scraps of urine and litter that are too small to remove. This causes me to empty out the box way more often than I would with a better performing litter. This litter is also very dusty when pouring.

I'll try most things once and that was enough for me. I'll not purchase it again for the following: 1. The dust from this rivals the Sahara. 2. Oh sure it clumps but don't try to remove the clump from the box. The second you touch it it crumbles into tiny little clumps that you can't scoop. 3. It has the consistency of concrete. Sliding the scoop through the litter required my strong arm. I'm sure my cats are thankful that today I dumped it all and switched litter brands.