We have been buying this cat litter for 3 yeas. The last bucket we bought smelled awful and was just dust. We had to wear a mask when even scooping the litter box because of all the dust and the smell. The new and improved is actually way worse and totally disgusting.

I thought it would live up to its claim of being "scoopable," but it didn't. The clumping breaks apart when scooped, so you end up with stinking powder spreading all over the litter box. Occasionally, there might be a clump here and there, but you can tell there is either a mixing defect or they are cutting corners. It's not worth the box it came in with.

We have been buying this litter for at least a year but they changed the formula. It does not clump any more and the cats won't use the box because it doesn't stay clean. It may scoop, but even that is not good. It was great before but now it's just cheap litter.

I decided to try this litter to save a few dollars. My husband and I have several cats, so we thought we would give it a try. It turned out to be the most dusty litter we have ever used and within a day our house started to smell! I absolutely do not recommend this litter in any way.

I have used this cat litter for 4 years and loved it until they changed the formula. There was a "new and improved formula" logo on the bucket. The new litter is not at all like it used to be. The litter now has a strong offensive chemical smell, and it no longer clumps, and also no longer masks the smell of cat urine. I am disappointed that Member's Mark changed a quality product into something that I can no longer use.

I bought this car litter during the height of Sam's not receiving deliveries quick enough during the pandemic. My usual clumping cat litter is fresh step and my Sam's was out of it.This cat litter is fair compared to fresh step. Very little odor control. I finally bought fresh step on line and mix fresh step with the Sam's litter to use up the Sam's litter. With the fresh step added in the odor control is much better. Yes, the pail is great and the cost is inexpensive but I won 't buy it again. I'll stick to fresh step that clumps, less dust and controls odor and costs more.

Somewhere over the past year they changed the formulation of this litter. It now is so full of dust that my cat leaves a trail all over the house when she exits the cat potty. The litter is a great value compared to other brands, but I'm not sure all the dust makes it worth the savings.

We've been buying this for years and never had a problem. Recently they changed the formula and now it's terrible. It's a darker color, smells different and worst of all it no longer clumps like it used to. I have trouble scooping now because it breaks apart so easily. We will no longer be purchasing this product.

I have bought this product for several years. I scoop out cat's litter daily and had always been happy with this product. This last couple of purchases; however, have turned me right off. I had always chosen this product because it was effective and economical but since it no longer works, I will buy it no more. It produces excessive dust and the urine no longer clumps and is not scoopable.

Bought this a few weeks back to try out. The dustcloud created pouring in is massive and lingers in the air for a good while. Even after sifting through it for minutes (with a medical mask on) to get it all out, its not enough. For days my poor 8yr old rescue Leia came out with watery eyes after covering up. Until now, get this.. she stopped covering. Yeah. 8 years of being "a cat" doing what cats are known for, centuries of instinct, and she now denies a felines "urge to bury the bad smell" because of this litter. WOW. I will gladly pay more for another brand.