This oil is great for cooking, but has a bitter aftertaste when used as a dip. The original Members Mark EVOO has a better flavor in my opinion.

I don't know what's going on, but this used to be good. The last several containers I have purchased the quality has gone down significantly. Complete garbage! I'm not buying this anymore.

It's great oil, but like so many other things you have to be a plus member to buy it. I realize they are trying to get more members to go to plus but if they keep removing items and services and making them plus is a regular membership worth it?

We've tried several brands of organic olive oil and Members Mark we think is the best. It is very aromatic and green in color (a good sign). This brand is very flavorful, it is our main oil for cooking, even subbing for butter in some meals. Glad that Sams Club has Member Mark. Finally the larger quart bottle is more convenient than and lasts longer and the plastic bottle has saved me multiple times from having to clean up a mess. Highly recommended.

This EVO is wonderful. I own a handmade organic soap business and this is the only OO I use in my soap recipes. My Castile soaps come out a beautiful light green shade whereas other OO will turn a faded beige green after saponification. Wonderful top quality and it shows in my products. Since I happen to have mountain of the bottles, we also use it to eat. Nice light pepper taste excellent on its own or for cooking. My ONLY complaint is the bottle only contains about 64oz of oil. I have a soap recipe that uses 66oz of EVO and I always need to crack open another bottle which prompted me to weigh the oil on a fairly accurate scale. 64 and some change every time. It would be wonderful if Sam’s could check this out. Otherwise, love this oil and price.

I buy this now on a regular basis for cooking, but this can also stand alone for it's great flavor. It has the most robust flavor of any EVOO Sam's carries, and even passes the "cough test" if you sip a little. Incredibly versatile. I buy numerous high end EVOO from around the world and for a fraction of the price this oil really holds its own. Best value you'll find anywhere and with a nice robustness.

Unclear origin

Best price around.

Bad batch?

Great product