Sam's must have a good turnover on their olive oil because I've never gotten any that smelled rancid. This has happened elsewhere when I bought the economy size.

The last few times I have purchased this I have been disappointed that the oil seems alot more liquidy than before, as if it has been watered down. And the flavor is not as good as before. The smell & taste is not as intense as before.

I am pleased with Member's Mark Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil, it is delicious for cooking, bread dipping, in the home made bread that I make every other day, in salves andlotions that I make

This olive oil is surprisingly good. I feel as though I gambled and WON. I usually buy small bottles of olive oil because it goes rancid quickly, so, buying this larger bottle of an untested oil was a gamble. It’s good!

Very nice for the price. Thin enough to spray in my Misto bottle, and organic so I am okay with using it for general cooking. I wouldn’t call this a flavorful finishing oil by any means. Just a good all purpose olive oil version of a work horse

I buy this brand all the time because it is real olive oil. There are a lot of products on the market that are not pure olive oil - they mix it with other oils. The taste and color are superior.

thank you so much for the extra seal on the oil it did not waste or spill a drop. I have been using this product for a long time but this is the first time I ordered it online.

This olive oil greatly surprised me. It still has the peppery aftertaste of fresh olive oil that most commercial grade oils lack because they are too old. Very impressed.

Love this stuff. the 3 liter is a better buy but for some reason Sams wants you to buy that in person now, because they have stock but dont want to ship it

The olive oil is great, but the bottle is flimsy and hard to handle. When I grasped the indented area to life the bottle the first time, oil spurted out and made a mess!