Skip to Main Content
Sams Club
Sams Club
Customer reviews for Member's Mark Grass Fed Beef NY Strip Steak, priced per pound for
Member's Mark Grass Fed Beef NY Strip Steak, priced per pound
4.1 out of 5 stars
stars1,357 ratings317 reviews
  1. 5 stars64% (867)
  2. 4 stars11% (155)
  3. 3 stars8% (112)
  4. 2 stars6% (79)
  5. 1 star11% (144)

Member photos

Sort by |
Showing 1-10 of 317 reviews
Aug 1, 2025
JB
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Good quality and flavorful steak

These are the best reasonably priced grass-fed sirloins I have found. Sized to what I should eat (not what I would like to eat). We ate some the day we bought them and several two weeks later having frozen them. There was no discernible difference.

Helpful?6BXAG6FA62095991138413
May 24, 2025
KandK
3 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Rib-eye was average

My husband cooked these steaks as he normally does, medium rare, and we were really looking forward to this occasional treat as we don’t often splurge on steak, but it was Mother’s Day and rib-eye is the best in our opinion. These were just okay; not as tender & juicy as we anticipated.

Helpful?6BXAG6FA62095991138413
Apr 26, 2026
Dennis
3 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Only once

was a little pricey but I bought it because was on sale. Won't do that again. Taste and tenderness were no better thyan choice sirloin.

Helpful?6BXAG6FA62095991138413
Sep 3, 2025
CAS
1 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Grilled Medium Rare Did Not Help

One grisly piece of meat. I bought several a month ago and they were great. Repurchased a week ago and a third of the serving was unusable. Grilled below medium rare did not help. Stay away from these.

Helpful?6BXAG6FA62095991138413
Sep 26, 2025
SB
1 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Don’t buy

The steaks were tough and full of gristle

Helpful?6BXAG6FA62095991138413
Oct 2, 2025
Charlene
1 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Gross steak

It was the toughest steak we’ve ever had!

Helpful?6BXAG6FA62095991138413
Aug 4, 2025
Brian
1 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Very tough steak.

Very tough. If you want to work on your jaw muscles, get these. On top of that, they weren't that tasty.

Helpful?6BXAG6FA62095991138413
Sep 15, 2025
Sue W
1 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Tough and tasteless

These steaks were cooked medium rare and were so tough and were tasteless, I was very disappointed as I bough two packages and ended up throwing them all away.

Helpful?6BXAG6FA62095991138413
Feb 22, 2025
scurry
1 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Grisly over dyed meat

Thiis organic steak was grisly and had so much red dye it them you could rub and egg on it and your Easter eggs are painted. It’s crazy to spend this amount of money for healthy organic foods only to consume a massive amount of coloring. It’s unhealthy and it wrong to make us think that dye is good for us. It’s gross and I chew every bite then spit the stuff I can get down into a napkin maybe actually consuming 1/4 of the grisly stuff.

Helpful?6BXAG6FA62095991138413
reply from Product Expert

Hello, please rest assured that the only ingredient in our Grass Fed NY Strip Steaks is 100% Australian Grass Fed and Finished beef. There are no artificial ingredients or dyes of any type.

Nov 2, 2024
Vin
1 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

A Disappointing Steak Experience

Thomas Farms Grass-Fed Beef I was excited to try Thomas Farms grass-fed beef, expecting a flavorful and tender steak. Unfortunately, my experience was quite the opposite. The meat had a strange, off-putting taste that strongly resembled liver. It was incredibly tough, making it difficult to chew, even when cooked slowly. I'm not sure what went wrong, but this steak was a major disappointment. I would advise others to steer clear of this particular product.

Helpful?6BXAG6FA62095991138413