I was shocked to read that one of these replaces a meal. My 2 fur babies loved it. I am not sure I agree with the meal replacement but we us it as a midday treat.

My dogs love these and I have been buying them for them for years. They don't always have them in store, and I live 25 miles from the closest Sam's so I am going to just order them online from now on.

My dog loves his treats and this is one of his favorites. When I am trying to work and he wants play time, this is a good substitute to keep him busy until I am able to provide my attention to play ball with him.

My dog loves these. Its too bad that it is gone in about 3 -4 bites because he is a big dog and a heavy chewer. Its his nightime snack before bed or if we go on long rides.

My dogs love them. However they still can chew one up in under 5 minutes. My daughter cut them in half and put them in a Kong and it takes the dogs a lot longer.

My dogs love these, I only give them one when I am going out leaving them. It takes my Lab 1min. or less to eat, my Small German Shepard 3 min. and my Female Boxer 20min to eat. Judge your purchase accordingly

Our Dog loves these. She eats them in a hurry because she is a heavy chewer. We have bought these 4 times. Some people said they are messy but we have not found them to be.

Our Great Pyrenees loves these! They are big enough for him to put between his paws to chew. He is very picky so it is great to find something to treat him with after a good visit to the dog park.

I bought these for our golden retriever puppies to chew on so they quit chewing the house but the back of the back says NOT FOR PUPPIES. So I rated it 3 stars since there's no way to say Not Applicable. My son's dogs love them.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] My dogs love them but im not crazy over the ingredients their something I give as a treat in a pinch!