My dogs love these, but the artificial red coloring gets on everything. If they are on a doggie blanker or bed, or a piece of our furniture, the darn stick stains it red after they've been chewing it.

Love these for both of my big dogs. I love the fact that it is a bigger bag than what you find in the regular grocery store and both of my dogs love these!

Dog loves these, but the color runs. If your dog eats these on a white or beige blanket, dog bed, etc., be aware that that red color runs and stains fabric. Adding dye to dog treats is so unnecessary.

I bought these for our golden retriever puppies to chew on so they quit chewing the house but the back of the back says NOT FOR PUPPIES. So I rated it 3 stars since there's no way to say Not Applicable. My son's dogs love them.

Gershwin (jack russell/beagle mix) dances for these treats. He reminds me (by staring me down and turning his head from side to side) when I am late in offering it to him on a daily basis.

Good size for a medium sized dog, and takes them a little while to chew. The power-chewer will finish one in about 10 minutes, while the other will take an hour or so, even though the dogs are about the same size.

I was shocked to read that one of these replaces a meal. My 2 fur babies loved it. I am not sure I agree with the meal replacement but we us it as a midday treat.

Our Great Pyrenees loves these! They are big enough for him to put between his paws to chew. He is very picky so it is great to find something to treat him with after a good visit to the dog park.

These are great looking treats with a lot of substance to them, but my small dogs (15 lbs) lose interest in them because they are so large and hard for them to handle. Probably really good for bigger dogs.

Although I’ve used this product before, it’s been a few years. With goldens who never had one, they both became ill from it. Like it wouldn’t digest. Gave them away.