These make my dogs so happy! My dogs recognize the bag that these come in. As a result, they are very vocal, telling me what they want. I highly recommend it for anyone who owns a dog, and would like to keep them busy for a good long time.

They are not an everyday treat for us, but the dogs jump for joy every time this bag gets pulled out of the pantry. Takes them a bit to chew through, so it’s an exercise for the teeth as well!m.

My Doggos love these treats and I have to say that they last a little longer , even though my dogs are big it makes them work for it!! I will continue to buy these!

I buy these as a special treat for my Australian shepherd and he loves them. I started buying them because they contain no rawhide. This bag of 18 is the cheapest I have found.

My dog loves this treat. I give it to her 3 days or less a week. She is always looking for it. When she finally gets one she snatch it and run off.

Love these for both of my big dogs. I love the fact that it is a bigger bag than what you find in the regular grocery store and both of my dogs love these!

My dog eats everything too fast and these help slow him down. Its great for teething pups and the ones that are on the larger side. My dog can't have rawhide until his puppy teeth are gone. Great alternative

Dog loves these, but the color runs. If your dog eats these on a white or beige blanket, dog bed, etc., be aware that that red color runs and stains fabric. Adding dye to dog treats is so unnecessary.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] My dog loves these! It last for about 10-15 mins for him to demolish. They keep him occupied for a good time. They must be mighty tasty too!

These are great looking treats with a lot of substance to them, but my small dogs (15 lbs) lose interest in them because they are so large and hard for them to handle. Probably really good for bigger dogs.