I didn't like this flavor as much as I thought I would. It's not bad, but maybe a little bland, and not as creamy as I had hoped either. I enjoyed it, but for me there are better flavors out there. I probably won't order this again any time soon, though I'll give it another chance down the road.

10/10 There were a lot of rave reviews about this one and I didn't buy into it. I figured it'd end up tasting like any Cookies and Cream protein shake... I was wrong! It was pretty spot on with the flavor it was aiming for and the texture of everything was perfect. No wonder it's the Founders Favorite! (21Aug)

Not bad. It was good—similar to Oreo flavored cereal, but I wasn't sure about it with the oatmeal texture. I think next time I will either stick it in the blender to make it smooth or use less milk to eat it thicker and hot to see if I can enjoy it better.

This is the first flavor I tried with chocolate in it and it was not good to me. It tastes like play dough smells. Maybe it's just my tastebuds but I don't like any of their flavors with chocolate. Something about whatever they use for chocolate just doesn't taste good to me. The fruit flavors and flavors without chocolate are superb though! I love them and the ease of this high protein breakfast. I'll keep ordering but will be adjusting my subscription picks. Highly recommend the non-chocolate flavors.

There was zero flavor to this. Nothing "cookies & cream" about this. It was plain boring oatmeal. There weren't even chia seeds in this pack. Not sure if this was perhaps just a dud pack that missed a couple of steps during production (??) because my other flavors have been amazing so far. Anyway, it pains me to say this but this one was a huge disappointment.

This flavor is pure comfort in a cup. Oats Overnight absolutely nailed the Cookies & Cream—it's creamy, chocolatey, and has that nostalgic cookie flavor without being overly sweet. It honestly feels like I'm having a milkshake for breakfast, but without the guilt. The texture is smooth and satisfying after soaking overnight, and the little cookie-like bits give it just the right amount of crunch and flavor contrast. It's indulgent, but still packed with protein and keeps me full all morning. If you're someone who likes dessert-for-breakfast vibes but still wants something balanced and energizing, this one's a must. Definitely one of my top favorites from their lineup!

My complaints so far are that the flavors are a little more muted than I expected and the sweetness is very low. Which, for the sweetness, I'm actually thankful for. So many "baked good" flavored items are sickeningly sweet, so being able to add a dash of sweetener is absolutely amazing. I'm surprised that these are so far as good as they are, I appreciate the protein content. Makes it extremely easy, with fairlife fat free mille to make an extremely easy grab and go hearty breakfast, under 400 calories and 30 g of protein.

Absolutely love the flavor of these overnight oats and I like the protein content. It really does taste like Cookies & Cream. I've had several flavors now including Apples & Cinnamon and Strawberries & Cream, and they all are delicious and filling. My only critique is I wish the sugar content was lower. Hopefully, the company will start making some overnight oats flavors with monk sugar & stevia to offer more variety to those of us that need lower sugar options.

The taste is awesome! I'm sure all of your flavors taste great by all the other reviews I've seen. I didn't realize that your primary protein source is pea protein and that was disappointing. It is my fault for not reading that pea protein was your primary protein source. Animal proteins are more complete proteins, containing all of the essential amino acids possible, while pea protein does not. I was hoping to pair your product with a fitness regimen and I still will occasionally but I hope one day you can use whey or the equivalent so I can maximize my gains and recovery.

I tried this warm and cold and its not bad at all warm, but cold?! Delicious like ice cream almost!! I can definitely get a kick of that cookie n cream vibe. Cold I used protein milk, cookies n cream greek yogurt, and mini oreos on top (after the gym haha) but I had it without the extras added first just to see what its like without, and this is a solid flavor.