The consistency is very offputting when made with a full 8 ounces of milk. I gagged every time I tried to drink it. I think next time I will use less milk and see if I could just eat it without issue (as the alternative prep). The flavor itself was OK. It wasn't oh my goodness wow but it wasn't terrible.

Wow. So far, I like ALL your flavors (except the coffee one... .I don't drink coffee)....cookies and cream is ESPECIALLY delicious!!! What do you think about this report that says that eating Oatmeal is not good for you?... I copied this from the email I got: While grains have been the FOUNDATION of the US government's food pyramid since 1992, they're actually terrible for you. In fact, they're the main dietary source of what's called anti-nutrients. You've probably already figured this out, but while nutrients are substances that nourish plants and animals to grow and live, anti-nutrients earn their title because they block the absorption of nutrients – especially those required for strong, healthy bones. If that sounds bad, it's because it is… And most of the grains you consume contain THREE of the worst anti-nutrients for your system. 1.) Lectins: these “sticky proteins” interfere with the absorption of calcium, iron, phosphorus, and zinc. Lectins are also closely linked to a condition known as “leaky gut.” Since they often attach to your intestinal wall, your stomach lining is compromised, allowing food particles (and waste) to slip into the bloodstream… Trigger an inflammatory response & digestive distress… And lead to symptoms like nausea, diarrhea and bloating. While lectins are not completely avoidable, grains are chock full of them. In fact, out of ALL the food groups, it's grains (and especially oatmeal) that contain the most lectins. >>> This is why I recommend you stay away from oatmeal and choose nutrient-dense foods with lower lectin levels for breakfast.

Nope! Nah! Hard pass! Gritty! Separated overnight and in between shaking it. Was just off. Couldn't tell the flavor either - had to double check what the package said. Don't know if this was an earlier version? The grittiness was like whey protein powders you can find that don't dissolve/mix/blend well.

I wasn't sure on this one due to some of the other reviews - but tried anyway and glad I did! I love this flavor. It takes more like the creme ore filling chocolate. What I like most is that while very tasty it is not too sweet. Some other flavors, while still delicious, they can verge on a tad in the too sweet side for my preferences. This had a great balance and I very much enjoyed the flavor!

I never thought my teenager would eat oatmeal. He saw my first box and said he'd give the cookies and cream a try. He's obsessed! I placed an order the NEXT day for more - he thinks it tastes great, keeps him full and is perfect for his busy schedule with hockey practice and daily workouts.

I've had a lot of protein shakes. I've had a lot of overnight oats. I had a lot of different oats and I think by far it was the least favorite of all my purchases however, I wanna give you guys a 10 out of 10 for the Marketing. You guys are doing great promoting this product but the taste is not there for me.

Cookies and cream is my favorite overall flavor for everything so I was expecting a lot in this flavor. I wish there were some little Oreos crumbs or something to elevate the cookies and cream flavor. Although it's a good taste still, I prob wouldn't order this over the other flavors I loved.

I was able to taste both the chocolate and the cream aspects of the flavor profile, which was a nice surprise. Also this flavor is a good candidate for a "short soak", so if you forget to put your OO in overnight (or are having a chocolate craving!), this flavor can be quick fix.

Cookies and Cream is one of those flavors you usually can't go wrong with. I was looking forward to this one but the flavor seemed off. Didn't have that sweet vanilla taste I enjoy and the cookies were so few and not quite right on the chocolate flavor either. Couldn't put my finger on it, but just didn't enjoy this one, personally.

This was the flavor that got me hooked. I split all flavors in half and mix half the package with plain overnight oats. I also doctor a lot of flavors with unsweetened cacao nibs, extra protein powder, and (if it is a chocolate or nut flavor) hazelnut milk. I know this is a huge departure from what the R&D team envisioned, but it works for me.