Thank you for sharing your feedback with us. While we're happy to hear that your dog likes Purina Busy With Peanut Butter Small/Medium Breed Dog Treats, we apologize for your experience. We want to gather more information about your preferences and help you further. Please get in contact with us by following this link: https://www.purina.com/contact-us. -The Busy Bones Team

We're thrilled to hear your dog loves our treat! Thank you for your loyalty and for choosing Busy Bone. We appreciate your support and are always here to help if needed: https://www.purina.com/contact-us. – The Busy Bone Team