I've tried 3 times and every time my German Shepherd eats one or my Biewer Terrier gets a small bite of one, they both get diarrhea. Total waste of $20 - wish I could return them for refund. 1 star for the enticing packaging. The contents need to be reformulated.

Purchased at Sam's Club today and gave one to my Abbey when I got home. I should have taken notice when she didn't take it at first. I now know why. Within 10 minutes she threw up the entire chew followed by one more episode of vomiting. Thankfully, this was the end of it. I then noticed these are made in Germany so who knows what they contain. I always check my dog's food/treats as to ingredients and where made. I never would have bought these. I fell down doing my job and my dog paid the price. Upon researching, I found other posts with the same problems. Will be returning these promptly!!! Will not stray again.

I have been buying these for years now and my dogs love them. I had one issue once before with one of my mastiffs, my youngest who got horrible diarrhea after eating one of these, so I have been super picky on looking these over every time I buy them. This time I purchased them on Nov. 5th and the product looked completlely different than it has in the past, grainy and white specs all in it. I said NOPE bad batch and threw both bags in the trash and decided to try it again on Nov. 14th. I opened the bags that I bought on Nov. 14th and the same issue, something is not right at all. I will not take a chance and give these to my babies, absolutely not. I called Sam's and reported it they immediately refunded me my money for both orders which is great and said they would send the information to my local Sam's Club. They did not contact with the maker of the product and stated they were in a different country so that's all they could do. Please be careful if you purchased these. There may be absolutely nothing wrong with them, but if it feels off, then it probably is. You can see the difference in the ones that I purchased on October 28th and they are smooth and look normal to the usual product as opposed to the ones purchased on Nov. 5th and Nov. 14th. A picture is worth 1000 words, right! Anyone else have this issue?

I have a 1 & 2 yr old Boxer. Both of my boys have food allergies/tummy issues & only eat special foods & treats. I happened to be in the club one day & decided to pick these up, since they were grain free, soy free, etc. my boys love these chews. It takes them about 5 mins to finish one. They have not had any tummy issues. My Boxers are very picky too, but they take these chews without any hesitation.

Just received two packages. My dogs have loved these in the past. We cut them up into thirds for smaller dogs. Noticed this time that they cut very easily and the texture is completely different. Used to look like caramels but now they have the look and feel of packed sawdust. Read the ingredients list and noticed they contain cellulose. Am I now buying sawdust?

We bought these about a week ago. The dog marginally likes them. He only eats ~75% of the treat. Additionally, The treat softens his poo. Since I live in an urban setting and have to pick up his job, its now more difficult to pickup. So for these two reasons I'm giving this treat 1 star. We won't be buying this one again.

I wish there was a CHICKEN FREE option. Otherwise my dogs love them.

All 3 of dogs got sick with vomiting and diarrhea.

This bones gave my dog really bad diarrhea I won't be buying them anymore..

My dog had the runs after eating one of these