My dog loves these treats… he knows them as “candy bars”. They are what I've used for years as the daily good-bye treat when I leave for work. It started with my last American Bulldog… they were the only way she'd let me leave for work without her in the morning. I now use these to barter with my 14 month old puppy, in hopes he doesn't destroy my house while I'm at work (sometimes he still destroys the house… just after he's had his tasty treat). They're supposed to be a “long lasting” treat, but with a 130 lb American Bulldog puppy… they don't last that long, maybe 4 chews. However, he LOVES his daily “candy bar”. Due to his breed, he has a lot of environmental and food allergies, but these don't seem to aggravate his allergies… which is why I choose stick with these. Unfortunately, the only way to get them now is to order them online with shipping, which charges an extra $8… RIDICULOUS! Sam's you're getting greedy. Bring them back in the stores. We pay a membership fee to shop in store for our convenience… not to mention these are a “Member's Mark” brand item, so they should be available IN STORE! I'm still going to order them… however, it will be reluctantly.

I use to buy these all the time, the last bag I got just sent my dog to vet and maybe ending up in hospital, he was throwing up round bits like another lady pictured I cut in half trying to figure out what it was, it was like a spongy potato piece. He ended up bleeding from the bile and very sick we aren't out of the woods yet

I wish they sold these back in the store again my dog absolutely loves these

My dog is addicted to these treats!!

Our German Shepherds love their nightly Munchy Bone.

Our lab, Mya, does a happy dance when it is treat time each night.

My dogs love these! They are a great snack.

My bulldog loves these things

My pooch LOVES these!!!!!

Great value chewy treat for my dogs