These taste like cardboard. No vanilla flavor, as is usually in shortbread, no buttery flavor, no flavor at all. If it wasn't such a hassle waiting in line to return these, I'd do it. Fancy packaging and crappy product.

Much too greasy now. I think the ones i used to get were not members mark... won't be getting anymore. Always looked forward to the holidays when these cookies were in stock.

I have bought these for years at Sam’s Club and this year they are horrible. They crumble into tiny crumbs with no taste. Horrible cookie! Not an enjoyable experience. I threw them away. That is how bad they were! I wouldn’t even give one star!

These cookies are delicious! Bought them in store last year and loved them, so I was delighted to find them online. Beware, though...I ordered 4 sets, and all the lovely tins in 2 of the sets came crushed/dented, so get them in store if you can.

These Shortbread cookies from Sam’s Club are incredibly delicious! We intended to gift them, but they were so good we kept them for ourselves. It’s disappointing they’re only seasonal; we wish they were available year-round!

Sorry, Member's Mark, you missed the mark with these. They literally tasted like lard. A shortbread cookie should taste like butter, not grease. They were so bad, our dogs weren't even impressed when I downgraded them to only suitable as a dog treat. Thank goodness we tried them first and I didn't just use the 4 pack as random thank you gifts during the holidays! For reference, I actually went back to several different shortbread cookie recipes I have, and each one uses BUTTER, not lard. Whoever did the taste test for you really failed. Perhaps using an easy to source shortbread cookie such as Walkers as your benchmark would help next year.

Theses are one of the best shortbread cookies I’ve ever tasted! One can was given 2 me at Christmas! I enjoyed them so much I order 2 more 4sets to give out! When I went to order more they are sold out! I have to with till Christmas time 2 order more! Everyone loves theses cookies!

Over half of the delivered cookies were crushed in each metal sleeve. There was no “Fragile” stamped on the outside so the box was treated like any other non-fragile package. Learned my lesson. Never order cookies that have to be shipped! I LOVE Sams but this was a bust!

Great shortbread cookies. These cookies were huge. Generally I buy those in cans and thet are tiny compared to what we received in this canasta. Everyone raved about the size of the shortbread. It was also very fresh tasting. Great Christmas present for yourself and for others.

Good shortbread cookies. If you are looking for one of the best store bought cookies, you’ve found it! If you want close to what Mon used to make back in the day, they are very close! Get yourself a hot cup of coffee, tea or coco and relax on a cold night in front of the fire and you’ll think you died and went to heaven. They are that good!