Both products work well with me however i have long hair, and the foam makes a mess and i can never really only use the amount they say. and their 3 month supply only lasts me 7-9 weeks. the extra strength lasts much longer. if you have short hair then either or should work for you. BTW my hair is longer than 4"

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] i was a skeptic at first, but as the months went by i truly felt my hair in general as being fuller and thicker, i would recommend rogaine for anyone who wants to make their hair look and feel healthier than it has in years! it really works!

I am very impressed by this product and am now kicking myself for not trying it many years ago. Yes - it took about four months to see results but now when I apply the foam I have a hard time even finding the bald spot I am trying to restore. I too was a doubter for years but I am now a lifetime user of this product!

I don't know why I'm surprised by this, but this stuff appears to work. And the only reason I sound less than completely enthusiastic has nothing to do with the product and everything to do with me. I'm averaging probably 1x/day on this, which means I'm barely giving it a fighting chance to work. And yet, it appears to be working in spite of me. I've used it now for about 5 months, and I can honestly see a difference. I can't imagine how much better it would work if I actually used it as directed. But there you go.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I've been using it for a month and a half as the crown of my head was thinning excessively. Now I can see the baby hairs covering my head again even though there is hair in my fingers whenever I apply the foam. Just make sure you apply twice a day as a routine. Foam is easy to apply. Minoxidil works, just have realistic expectations.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] This has helped me regrow my hair, mostly on top where my hair line was receding. I use twice a day and noticed an improvement about a month after beginning to use it. I have noticed I have yo wash my hair more often as it does have a slight smell after a couple of days but it is otherwise unscented

Many years ago a local radio personality used to talk about Rogaine and how it was helping to restore his hair and reverse his hair loss. I always figured it was a put on and just a glorified advertisement. About three years ago, I began losing my hair. I was in my late 40's and had a family history of hair loss. I remembered the radio show I used to listen to and thought I would give it a try. I used the product as recommended. At first, I saw no improvement and if fact, I seemed to be losing more hair than ever. Then, all of a sudden, it stopped and there was a noticeable increase in the density of hair and within six months, it was back to the way it had always been. I doubted the progress and stopped using the product and the hair loss returned. I restarted use and have used it ever since. There are cheaper alternatives out there but they feel make my hair feel heavy and dirty. I've tried several and always come back to Rogaine. It works and it has a better feel and look that any other product I've tried. I'm a believer.

Men's Rogaine Foam worked out for a good friend of mine but not sure if it's going to turn out so great for me. It doesn't smell bad and it isn't heavy feeling. I just haven't noticed any new growth yet. I have only been using the product for a couple weeks and I have been told (the product also states) it can take a few months to have a noticable difference. I'm going to see it through.

I was skeptical about this product at first, but after the 4 months i would have to say that I was wrong. I applied the product as directed, in the beginning it did look like it was getting worse, after the 4 months there is a big difference. Although it is not completely gone my bald spot hs decreased dramatically.. thank you for choosing me as a product tester. I would recommend this product for men that have this problem and it bothers you. I would say that spending the money for a 6 month supply would be beneficial.

I tried up to 4 products and they worked very little- The lady that cuts my hair sold me a very well known brand and still did not see enough results- I hesitated about Rogaine thinking it was just a myth , until I said why not try it - its not going to hurt- I bought a 3 month supply of extra strength and just now into my 2nd month and I can tell a difference in fuller hair in the middle- my hair stylist noticed a difference- She also said one key factor is use it the rest of your life which I have no problem after hearing my brother in law paid $15,000 for a new hair treatment! KEY TIPS THAT WORKED FOR ME Have a great nutrition program Have a vitamin supplemental program Exercise regular weekly Use a paraben free shampoo with a comb