Super moist and flavorful

This cake was a family favorite during the holidays. It was so moist and just absolutely delicious that I would definitely recommend and plan to buy again.

The cake looks beautiful and is really sweet, however, the distinctive taste associated with a cream cheese frosting was lacking and frankly, very disappointing.

I was very disappointed with this cake. It was dry and had very little taste. The icing didn't taste like cream cheese either. I have always been pleased with the desserts from Sam's, but not this one.

I think I may have just gotten a bad cake. It tasted quite burnt, which was a letdown. I would have returned it, but I was traveling out of state the next day and didn't have the time. I've heard great things, so I'm sure it's usually tasty, but this particular one was a miss.

This is not the same Red Velvet cake from last year - 2024! That Red Velvet cake was much richer in flavor, taller (for some reason this cake even looks smaller) and there were chocolate decorations on top. Not sure what happened but please bring back the previous year's cake. Your cakes are what make you (Sam's Club) competitive with Cosco.

This is not the Red Velvet Cake that I am accustomed to getting from Sam's during the holidays. It is a terrible substitute, and I'm so disappointed with this purchase. I should have realized it was off when I saw how it was decorated compared to the past ones I've purchased. The delicious, rich flavor of the cake they used to have is gone, replaced by watered down flavor. Even the color of the cake seems wrong. The texture of the cake is something between airy and crumbly and the frosting seemed overwhipped. This purchase felt like a waste of good money and calories.

every year my family buys the red velvet cake for christmas festivities and every year I look forward the delicious rich and moist cake that it used to be. we will no longer be purchasing seeing that they have changed the recipe. it is now a flavorless, dry brick. the icing also sucks compared to the previous cake. it is no longer a smooth cream cheese icing but a bland icing that falls off the cake in chunks. very disappointed and won't be repurchasing until they bring the old cake back.

Horrible taste :(

I rarely write reviews but felt compelled to write a review on this horrible tasting cake. I have looked forward every year to purchase what was once one of the best tasting red velvet cakes for the price. Apparently, Sam's has changed the cake to this cheap terrible tasting imposter. If I could leave a 0 star for this cake I would. How disappointing that Sam's would sell this to their members.