Thank you for reaching out to us. We’re sorry to hear that your cats did not enjoy the Purina Friskies lil’ Lickables With Chicken, Tuna or Ocean Whitefish Variety Pack Lickable Cat Treat. We understand that every cat has unique preferences, and finding the right treats can sometimes be a challenge. We’d appreciate the opportunity to learn more about your cat’s tastes so we can better assist you in finding a product they’ll enjoy. Please don’t hesitate to contact us through the following link: https://www.purina.com/contact-us. - The Friskies Team