Awful!!! I have purchased this pie for years because it was so good. They have ruined it. Please bring back the original!

The new cookie crust is HORRIBLE! Sam's Club needs to bring back the traditional french silk pie crust.

Bring back the original Chocolate Silk Pie! Original size and original crust was perfect, why do you have to mess with something that was so tasty.

Tried this the other day. Yummmm. It is now my 'go to" dessert. It will easily serve 10-12, and I eat large portions.

I loved the French Silk pie you have had in previous years. I just tried the 2025 version and it is a huge disappointment.

Very creamy. great flavor, the crust was very tasty, a bit crumbly, but delicious! I highly recommend this pie

I agree with many here. The new chocolate crust has seriously degraded the taste of the pie. Go back to normal pie crust and get rid of this crust!!

Delicious French silk pie! The filling was smooth and rich, and the chocolaty crust made it even better.

this pie tastes at first like french silk pie and then quicly has a windex/ammonia tastes. disgusting and most likely not safe to eat!

This is a wonderful pie, much better than what Sam's had last year. I will be buying 2 more for upcoming events