I was really excited to try these because I prefer vanilla over chocolate in general, and I've never seen vanilla shakes at Sam's before. I am extremely disappointed that as soon as I opened it, I noticed an eggy smell. I thought that maybe I imagined it and took a sip, but it tasted just as bad. I opened another in case it was a fluke, but it had the same smell. I'll be dumping all of these out as it seems they're spoiled, even though it says they're good until November this year.

Love these!! I drink one of these every day to help get more protein, they are better than the premier protein, doesnt have that aftertaste. These are literally just the fairlife milk but cheaper, seen they have strawberry flavor too and hoping for more flavors!!!

Taste not too bad but not as good as Fairlife Nutrition Plan Chocolate. The Members Mark not only have a shrink wrapped seal around the neck nut also a foil seal on the top on the bottle, both are a pain to remove. Fairlife is mush easier to open also as it is just a twist to break the plastic ring off the lid.

I actually like the taste of the shake and vanilla is my favorite flavor. However, I won't be purchasing this product again. Opening the bottle is too much work and impossible to open if you're on the go. Many senior citizens drink protein shakes and should be considered. The bottle can be recycled but it must be rinsed and saved for recycling day. More work. Competitors have biodegradable containers.

I like this drink and will buy it in place of the name brand. My only problem is the packaging. Please make it easier to get into. The outside wrapper is annoying to unwrap. This makes it hard to grab and go on your way to work. I can open the other brands while driving.

I'm always skeptical of these drinks having odd notes and tastes, especially since I typically associate Member's Mark brand as cheap knock off versions of popular brands, but they nailed it with this one - tastes just like a vanilla milk shake! Personally, I prefer to refrigerate them and drink them cold rather than room temp. Will definitely continue buying these!

This is the worst protein shake I have ever had. I usually but Premier (powder or premade), but I tried it because of the price. BIG MISTAKE! When I opened it, I noticed a very unppealing oder , I thought it was spoiled. I had my wife take a sip and she said it was most likely the container and also a cheap vanilla flavoring. She said it was sub par. There is no accounting for taste, but I will not be buyIng it again no matter what the price.

Tastes just like melted vanilla ice cream. Some of the best tasting protein shakes I have had to date. Great on it's own or in my coffee. And for a really special treat mix with A%26W Root Beer (Zero or regular dealer's choice). Tastes just like a root beer float.

i like the product it tastes good. but the packing is a pain. the box is over glued and hard to open. the bottles are fully wrapped and a pain to tear into, then after you open the lid there is another seal. should take some tips from Fairlife's packaging they use the same bottles.

I thought this would be a great alternative to Fairlife, and at a better price. The packaging is too many layers of plastic. When you remove the foil seal there are still some bits on the bottle. It makes me worry about ingesting too many micro plastics. Also, it doesn't have the same vitamins and minerals as Fairlife. And it's only available in vanilla.