i was hoping this tasted more like fairlife vanilla but definitely not. this taste just like premiere protein. but at least it doesnt have weird slimy chunks of unknown origin like premiere. DOES NOT TASTE LIKE A MILKSHAKE AT ALL. but the price is nice if you tolerate premiere proteins.

I wanted to love this because it quite a bit cheaper than the Nurri brand but there were a few cons I cannot get passed. I've had it happen twice where I find little clumps at the bottom and swallowing these were gross. Alongside to that, there's a film that formed at the rim of the bottle that got stuck to my lips and grossed me out too.

I had previously bought the Member's Mark chocolate shakes in the cardboard material and they were good. These I bought by accident and thought they were packaged in cardboard material however these were in plastic bottles. Not only are they difficult to open the shake have a plastic after taste that is hard to ignore.

These taste really good-but if you decide to only drink part of it and put the lid back on to wait to finish for later-next time you open, it literally smells like the sewer! It was their weirdest thing. I can't get over the overwhelming smell of sewer gases while taking the lid off.

Great flavor and would purchase again except that it has clumps of undissolved protein powder at the bottom of every bottle. No amount of shaking will discover it. One thing I can't stand is having to chew on clumps of protein powder. Afraid to give it another go so moved back to Nurri.

This tastes fine, but it's really hard to get open. It has a tough plastic wrap then a foil lid under the cap. Compared to Fairlife and Premier Protein which both only have twist to open caps, Member's Mark has too many barriers. It's good, but the packing needs some work.

Just bought 2 cases of this thinking Members Mark would be a good product, the vanilla just tastes terrible! Has some chemical taste, and absolutely nothing like the vanilla ice cream they show on the case. If you have had fair life 42 vanilla or Nurri, those are so good and this is just bad! Please don't call it vanilla ice cream when it tastes nothing like that . Sadly such a disappointment since I was expecting this to be tasting at least as good as other ultra filtered vanilla drinks. I'm stuck with two cases now, which tastes nothing like vanilla, but a very weird taste and smell.

While the taste isn't that bad the smell is. I don't know what ingredient they added that does that but it smells like someone farted in the bottle at the plant that makes them. My son drank one and said it's not bad but it smells aweful. Fix the smell and you have a winner.

The macros on this shake are great, and it tastes great too! It has a strange scent to it (almost like eggs if I had to find a way to describe it?) which can be a little off putting. It can also be difficult to open a bottle with the plastic wrapper and then foil seal, but that's not too big of a drawback.

I thought this would be a great alternative to Fairlife, and at a better price. The packaging is too many layers of plastic. When you remove the foil seal there are still some bits on the bottle. It makes me worry about ingesting too many micro plastics. Also, it doesn't have the same vitamins and minerals as Fairlife. And it's only available in vanilla.