I usually get premier protein shakes but thought I’d give these a try. These have a unique after taste, plus there isn’t enough vanilla flavor to them. I got them to use as a coffee creamer but end up adding a little more syrups and flavors to make it work.

Great tasting protein drink that taste like a milkshake! This protein drink is easy to swallow and digest. Great flavor comes in vanilla strawberry. I would highly recommend this as a additional protein drink or a meal replacement for a fast snack or lunch!

In comparison to other protein shakes on the market, this one is more cost effective. Strong vanilla flavor without lingering aftertaste. High in sodium, which many of these types of shakes are. Ultimately ended up using as an additive to morning coffee.

No matter how much I shake it there is a bunch of Clumpy congealed powder floating around.

Great flavor and texture! That isn't always the case with some protein drinks which can come off as a bit gritty or chalky. I appreciate the 30 g of protein and only 150 calories per serving. As I say the flavor is great as is, but would make a good base blended with some fruit as a smoothy for a post-workout drink.

I purchased this on 30 December, 2025. We drink the Members Mark Chocolate version and saw the vanilla and decided to try it. First of all, trying to get it open. The shrink wrap on the lid is very hard to get off. Then there is an additional foil on the inside which is tough to get off. I shake it will. Then the taste. It's nothing special, just okay. The worst part is the chunks on the bottom that will not dissolve with all the shaking in the world. The last couple of swallows contain chunks of whatever is stuck to the bottom of the container.

I never leave reviews- positive or negative. However the reviews on these shakes lead me to believe these were close to the fairlife shakes and they are not anywhere near the same. I couldn't get past the awful smell as soon as your crack the cap. I quickly found on google that is very common for these shakes to have a odor due to the filtration process. The instant smell of eggs or like they had gone bad was and immediate no.

Lumpy, will not dissolve. Makes me doubt it delivers the full promised nutrients. Chalky taste.

This protein shake is creamy and has a very good vanilla flavor. No chalky taste at all. Pleasantly surprised. I purchased several more after initial purchase.

It's okay. Probably decent for the price. But not comparable to the Fairlife brand. The flavor is good, but no matter how much you shake it up, there is always unmixed residue at the bottom of the bottle.