I think it might have been a fluke with the ones I purchased as these have good reviews. Mine tasted like burnt plastic. I took one sip and back they went. Good on Sam's for a no hassle return! They are also a pain in the rear to get to. First a strip for the lid to wrestle off, then a super secure peel off seal. A bit of an overkill if you ask me or anyone really.

This protein shake is so much better than I imagined! I've tried other vanilla flavored protein shakes and couldn't stand the taste. This one is very smooth and tastes great! It reminds me of homemade ice cream (in liquid form, of course). It also has a whopping 30 grams of protein and is easier on your wallet. I highly recommend it!

Wow! Very pleased with these members mark vanilla milk shakes!!! My kids and I both love them! They taste healthy, but also are a nice treat! No chalky aftertaste and great flavor!! Very impressed because I normally hate things like this. They are smooth and not too thick. Thicker than milk, but not as thick as you would think. They are the consistency a tad bit smoother than the yogurt smoothie drinks. I will absolutely be buying these again.

In comparison to other protein shakes on the market, this one is more cost effective. Strong vanilla flavor without lingering aftertaste. High in sodium, which many of these types of shakes are. Ultimately ended up using as an additive to morning coffee.

I bought the vanilla one time to try and it tastes like the plastic bottle. I like how it's package with the double security seal but the flavor is lacking. I am using it in my coffee to get rid of it as it does have great nutritional value and I don't like to waste anything. However the strawberry is fantastic.

No matter how much I shake it there is a bunch of Clumpy congealed powder floating around.

this was so good and comparable to fairlife however the last case that I bought had chunks in it and it was awful deff do not recommend after that. And i know protein creates them but when your drink 75% and its good and you go to drink the rest and its curdy NOT GOOD

This pre-bottled protein shake from Sam’s Club is honestly one of the best grab-and-go options I’ve tried. The milkshake-style flavor is what really stands out—it’s smooth, creamy, and actually enjoyable, not chalky or overly artificial like many other protein drinks. It feels more like a treat than a supplement, which makes it easy to stick to daily. Nutritionally, it delivers exactly what you’d want: a solid amount of protein per bottle, low sugar, and a good balance for post-workout recovery or even as a quick meal replacement when you’re busy. It keeps me full for a couple of hours without feeling heavy or bloated.

Great tasting protein drink that taste like a milkshake! This protein drink is easy to swallow and digest. Great flavor comes in vanilla strawberry. I would highly recommend this as a additional protein drink or a meal replacement for a fast snack or lunch!

I never leave reviews- positive or negative. However the reviews on these shakes lead me to believe these were close to the fairlife shakes and they are not anywhere near the same. I couldn't get past the awful smell as soon as your crack the cap. I quickly found on google that is very common for these shakes to have a odor due to the filtration process. The instant smell of eggs or like they had gone bad was and immediate no.