So, I really like Muscle Milk Protein shakes in the 18 pack, they are my favorite. These Sam's Club protein drinks are better than average, but not near as good as Muscle Milk, I've tried the Premier Protein Vanilla, and while the Sam's shakes have a similar taste, I think these are actually better. Smoother and less aftertaste.

I workout everyday and drink multiple protein everyday. This one tastes the best by far. I usually make my own from a powdered mix and it tastes a little chalky. The flavor of this protein shake is creamy and smooth. I also appreciate the higher protein content. Great product.

Received these shakes, and was pleasantly surprised by the taste. I normally do not like protein shakes but gave these a try and I definitely would buy these! Great taste and a nice start to my day! No disturbing after taste, and they smell great too.

This Member's Mark prtoen shake was really good. The consistency was smooth, and it wasn't at all thick. I've had some that are so thick , you have to chew them! I got the Vanilla flavor, and it remided me of the new Oikos drink. My teenager thought it was similar to Fairlife. This does have 2 grams of sugar and 130 calories. Not terrible for 30g of protien, but you can't say it doesnt have any sugar. This will be something my family gets for post workout!

I was honestly surprised by how good these shakes taste. The vanilla flavor is smooth, creamy, and not overly sweet like a lot of protein drinks. They’re perfect on their own for a quick breakfast or post-workout snack, but they’re even better poured over ice with coffee for an easy homemade vanilla latte. The texture stays rich without being heavy, and the high protein keeps me full for hours. Definitely one of the best ready-to-drink shakes I’ve tried, especially for the price and convenience.

These are so good! I've tried quite a few different brands of protein shake with my daily protein coffee and this may be my favorite. These are definitely going to be a staple in my fridge from now on! The vanilla flavor is yummy and there's no weird aftertaste like these kind of drinks sometimes have.

I was pleasantly surprised by how good this tastes! The vanilla flavor is smooth, creamy, and doesn’t have that chalky protein shake aftertaste that a lot of other drinks have. It honestly tastes more like a milkshake than a protein drink. With 30g of protein and only 150 calories, it’s an easy way to add extra protein during a busy day. I’ve also gotten creative with it — it tastes great mixed into iced coffee for a vanilla protein coffee, and I’ve even blended it with ice to make a healthier ice-cream-like treat. It’s versatile, convenient, and actually enjoyable to drink. Definitely keeping these stocked in my fridge!

Not bad flavor for a vanilla protein shake. It's not very thick. I can taste the after taste of the Stevia leaf, which isn't my favorite, but it's not horrible. Overall if you are looking for a protein drink with lots of protein and not a ton of calories this is great for you.

This vanilla milkshake leans more toward a high-protein dairy drink than a traditional indulgent shake. The texture is smooth and creamy without being overly thick, making it easy to drink while still feeling satisfying. The vanilla flavor is mild and clean, which is a plus if you prefer something balanced. It doesn’t have that heavy, sugary aftertaste you get with many ready-to-drink shakes. Because it’s ultra-filtered, it packs in a higher protein content and less sugar than typical milkshakes, making it a practical option for a quick breakfast or post-workout drink. One downside is that if you’re expecting a rich, ice-cream-shop style milkshake, this may fall a bit short. Overall: A solid choice if you want a convenient, better-for-you milkshake alternative with good protein and a smooth finish, but not the best pick if you’re craving a true dessert experience.

The members mark ultra-filtered milk shake works great for my post workout. The vanilla has a really good taste and is easy to drink. I do like it already chilled and cold. It’s only 150 calories with 30 grams of protein. I recommend this product and can’t wait to try the other flavors.