This has great flavor. Sweet but not overwhelming. It's very smooth and on the lighter side as opposed to being thick or chunky like others I've tried. I'm a sucker for vanilla and it didn't disappoint. Happy with the protein content, only four stars because of the mix of extra ingredients artificial sweeteners and preservatives.

I have used many different brands of pre-mixed protein shakes/drinks over the last 7-8 years. This one ranks up as one of the best tasting. I had bariatric surgery about 6 treats ago and need to keep my protein intake up. Drinks like this help tremendously. It also does not feel “chalky” when you are drinking it. I would definitely recommend.

I like the taste for a protein shake, i would compare to muscle milk. I usually do chocolate, seems like the chocolate help with the protein shake taste. This one was vanilla and it wasn't bad, real smooth. Great value for the price anf cane in plastic bottle which seems to work better for me when setting down compared to box containers.

This milkshake is not a bad alternative for a glass of milk. Most of the ingredients are comparable to a glass of milk, with the biggest differences being much higher sodium, less sugars and more protein. Overall the taste isn't too bad and us surprisingly sweeter than I was expecting.

What a tasty protein drink! Our family are avid consumers of protein products and are always looking for new drinks. This vanilla flavored one from Sam's Club fit the bill. It is smooth and does not leave a funny aftertaste or feeling in the mouth like some do. While comparing labels it is very similar to another brand which we love but can not find a vanilla flavor in so this gives us a great alternative! The bottles are larger than some other products we have had as well with a lower calorie per ounce which is great for those watching that in their diets. Overall, this is a solid choice for a protein drink and we will add it to our rotation. My only complaint is that the larger bottle size doesn't fit in my fridge as well as some of the other packaging but we can rearrange.

Not sure why you feel it necessary to package these so different from the chocolate. Same fluid ounce, same # of items in a box (12 vs 15) makes no sense. The square boxes you use for chocolate are much easier to open. Doubt I'll buy the vanilla again unless the packaging changes.

These vanilla milk shakes have become part of my morning routine. I grab one on the way out the door and I'm set. No prep, no mess, just a solid 30 grams of protein to start the day. The vanilla flavor has a great taste. That's not always been the case with some brands. It's not overly sweet or chalky, and the protein is smooth with no clumping. For anyone trying to hit protein goals without the hassle of cooking or blending anything, these are a practical option worth keeping in the rotation. The 12-pack size makes it easy to stock up and not think about it for a while. Solid product.

​If you are looking for a protein shake that actually tastes like a treat rather than a chore to drink, the Member's Mark Ultra-Filtered Vanilla Protein Shake is a fantastic find. ​The standout feature is the texture. Because it is ultra-filtered, it lacks that chalky or gritty mouthfeel that plagues so many other pre-made shakes. It is incredibly smooth and creamy, reminiscent of a vanilla bean milkshake but without the heavy sugar load. The vanilla flavor is balanced—sweet enough to satisfy a craving but clean enough that it doesn't leave a lingering artificial aftertaste.

This truly tastes like a vanilla milkshake. Many of the protein shakes after weird after taste but this Member's Mark version does not. I have drank it by itself but I also have put it in coffee, made instant pudding and put in a blender with ice and strawberries. DELICIOUS. Definitely recommend.

I was so pleasantly surprised by these protein shakes. I have been drinking a more expensive competitive brand for some time and was excited to give these more affordable shakes a try. These taste just like a creamy vanilla milk shake. There is no chalky taste at all. It is so nice to be able to get a 30 gram protein shake for an affordable price. I would most definitely recommend these.