These shakes are so creamy, smooth and delicious! They taste just like vanilla ice cream and they don't have an after taste like most protein shakes do. The high protein means they are a great meal replacement if you are in a hurry. Super filling without the heavy weighed down feeling you get sometimes. Will definitely be buying them again

The Good stuff - That protein count is no joke — 30g of protein in one little 11.5 oz bottle? That's genuinely impressive. Great for post-workout or just hitting your daily macros without much effort. - Almost zero sugar guilt — Only 2g of sugar with 0g added sugars. They're using sucralose and monk fruit to sweeten it, so you're not sacrificing taste for a sugar spike. - Clean label for a ready-to-drink — No artificial colors, no carrageenan, no artificial growth hormones. For a Sam's Club store brand, that's actually better than a lot of name brands. The Not-So-Good - Sweetener aftertaste — Sucralose and acesulfame potassium together can leave a lingering artificial sweetness that some people really can't get past. - Sodium is kinda high — 300mg per serving (13% DV) is a lot for what's essentially a flavored milk drink. If you need a convenient, low-sugar, high-protein grab-and-go drink and you're not too picky about it tasting like an actual milkshake, this is solid value especially at Sam's Club bulk pricing.

My whole family loved these vanilla protein shakes. They are smooth and don't have an after taste or chunks like some others I've purchased. My teenage son likes to substitute milk in his cereal with the vanilla flavor to add extra protien to his breakfast in the morning.

MM Ultra filtered Milkshake arrived in good condition. The Vanilla flavor is not over powering, good tasting, no aftertaste. Tried it at room temperature and tried it chilled-i prefer it chilled but great either way. Drank it before a workout. I would recommend this product for purchase .

I recently tried the Member's Mark Ultra Filtered Vanilla Milk Shake, and it's a solid choice for anyone looking for a convenient, high protein drink. The vanilla flavor is classic and sweet without being overpowering. It doesn't have that heavy artificial aftertaste that some protein have. It tastes very much like a melted vanilla milkshake. I love that these are packed with protein while keeping the sugar content relatively low. It's a great way to hit my macros without feeling like I'm drinking a diet drink. Overall high protein drink that actually tastes like a treat. It's best served ice cold! I'll definitely be keeping these stocked in my fridge for busy mornings.

If you are looking for a quick way to get some extra protein without a chalky texture, these are a great option. Pros: Taste: The vanilla flavor is pleasant and reminds me of a traditional melted milkshake rather than a medicinal supplement. Texture: Because it's ultra-filtered milk, the consistency is very smooth and creamy. It isn't thick or heavy, making it easy to drink on the go. Convenience: The 11.5 fl. oz. size is perfect for a quick snack or a post-workout boost. Cons: Aftertaste: The only real downside is a noticeable "fake sugar" taste. While the initial flavor is great, the artificial sweeteners do linger a bit on the palate afterward. Final Verdict: It tastes pretty good for a high-protein shake! If you're used to stevia or monk fruit sweeteners, you probably won't mind it at all. It's a convenient, tasty, and cost-effective alternative to name-brand protein shakes.

I tried the vanilla protein milk shake. It had a smooth, creamy texture and a nice vanilla flavor that didn't taste overly artificial. For a protein shake, it was actually really good and easy to drink. The best part was how filling it was — after drinking it in the afternoon, it kept me from craving the usual afternoon snack. It was not a heavy drink - just right. Overall, it's a solid option if you want something tasty, convenient, and satisfying. The only reason I didn't give it 5 stars is I didn't like the smell and that is just a personal issue on my part.

The flavor of this protein shake is excellent. It has a nice, smooth vanilla flavor that isn't fake or overpowering. It really does taste just like a milkshake! It is just the the consistency- not too thin, not too thick. It isn't chalky or powdery and goes down smooth. However, I have to give this 3 stars due to the packaging that makes this very difficult to open. The bottle is wrapped in plastic that goes up and around the lid, so you have to peel the plastic off from the lid to be able to screw it off. There is also a metal seal glued down around the opening of the bottle. It is so tight to the bottle that it makes it very difficult to pull it off. I usually buy the Fairlife brand protein drinks and those simply have the screw-on cap; no seal and no plastic up over the top. I really like the flavor of this drink but I am hesitant to purchase more unless the packaging is changed. I understand the seals are for safety and to prevent leakage but I feel there has to be a better way than struggling to get the bottle open every morning. I do recommend this product for flavor - but just keep in mind you'll need that extra protein to get the bottle open!

I am always looking for easy ways to add protein into my diet as I try and maintain a healthy lifestyle. I found this milkshake to be creamy enough to feel almost like a treat. It didn't upset my stomach like many drinks do. The texture and consistency is superior to a protein shake for me personally - it didn't gross me out! Taste wise, it's pretty good. I did try adding this into my coffee but it didn't work very well for my liking

These high protein vanilla milkshakes were a lot better than I anticipated. I am not one for milkshakes but if you serves this really cold it's really good. Taste like ice cream. It does have a little of after taste which is why I gave it 4 stars. And it's not super thick like some protein shakes. 30g of protein in one serving is hard to beat!