I was very surprised by these toys. Only one of them my dog was able to shred it and take out the whistle. The other 3 are going strong. 1 of these at Marshall’s/Tj Maxx would by 8.99-9.99. So definitely a great great buy!!!!

Terrible. Each toy lasted less than half a day with my 4 year old 50 pound mix German Shepherd. Money down the drain.

High quality, tough enough to last a little while and large enough for a medium to large dog. Very nice and worth the price